Blog
Italian-American Chicago: Little Italy and the Near West Side
How Italian immigrants built Taylor Street and the Near West Side, what the 1960s university campus took, and where Italian Chicago's food traditions live now.
Five hundred grocery stores. Two hundred fifty-seven restaurants. Two hundred forty pastry shops. That was the count of Italian-owned businesses in Chicago in 1927, and it describes a food economy that went from almost nothing in two generations: in 1880 the entire city had 1,357 people of Italian birth. Most of them stepped off the train, found a room and got a first job in one stretch of the Near West Side, centered on Taylor Street. The neighborhood that inherited the name Little Italy has since been squeezed, rebuilt and renamed. But how it fed and housed an immigrant city is one of the central stories in Chicago's food history.
Where it is
The Near West Side is the community area just west of the Loop and the river. Little Italy sits on its southern half, along Taylor Street and the blocks around it, between the Eisenhower Expressway on the north and Roosevelt Road on the south. These days the same stretch also goes by University Village, a name borrowed from its neighbor, the University of Illinois Chicago. ZIP codes in the area include 60607, 60608 and 60612. The CTA Blue Line stops at UIC-Halsted, which drops a rider at the corner of Halsted Street and the campus, a short walk from Taylor Street. The wider neighborhood is described in West Loop and Fulton Market and the downtown core nearby in The Loop.
Arrival: from the 1850s to 1930
Italians began arriving in Chicago in small numbers in the 1850s. The count was 1,357 by 1880, and then it jumped. The foreign-born Italian population of the city was 16,008 in 1900 and peaked at 73,960 in 1930. Most came from southern Italy and Sicily, and they settled in clusters organized by the village or region they had left. Taylor Street became the main arrival point, which is why it holds the name Little Italy. Other clusters sprang up around the city. One on the Near North Side, called Little Sicily and, less kindly, "Little Hell," had about 20,000 Italians by 1920, and Cabrini-Green was later built on its site. Another, the Heart of Italy, centered on 24th Street along South Oakley Avenue, still feels like a small Italian commercial street.
The new arrivals worked in construction, the railroads, factories and the food trades, and they founded the churches and societies that held the neighborhood together. Holy Guardian Angel, the first Italian congregation in Chicago, was established as a parish in 1898, and its church was built in 1899. It was later demolished for the expressway system. Our Lady of Pompeii, founded in 1911, is now a shrine and still stands on the neighborhood's southern edge. A parish in an Italian neighborhood was more than a church. It ran a school, a social calendar and the processions that carried a saint's statue through the streets on the feast day, and those processions are the ancestors of the street festivals Italian neighborhoods still hold.
The Hull House neighborhood
The Near West Side was not only Italian. When Jane Addams and Ellen Gates Starr opened Hull House on September 18, 1889, they called the area around it the Hull House neighborhood, and it held immigrants from a dozen countries. Records suggest the inner core was mostly Italian as early as the 1890s. The settlement house taught English, ran a kindergarten and a public kitchen and organized programs for the immigrants around it. The story of the settlement is told in Hull House and the settlement movement. For Italian Chicago the point is that a newcomer could find housing, a church, a job and a school all within a few blocks, often in a language they already spoke.
The food economy of a neighborhood
A neighborhood of 500 groceries and 240 pastry shops, even counted across a whole city, was a neighborhood where food was the main street's main business. Think what an Italian immigrant family needed in the first decades of the twentieth century. Olive oil, cheeses, cured meats and dried pasta were not on the shelves of the corner store run by someone from another country, so Italians imported them or made them. Bakers made the bread that anchored a meal. Butchers made sausage the way their regions did. Pastry shops sold the cookies and cakes that went with weddings, baptisms and feast days.
Out of that world came the dishes Chicagoans now think of as local. The Italian beef sandwich, thinly sliced roast beef served on a roll with its juices, is the most famous. The post italian beef: dipped, hot and sweet describes the sandwich and the traditions around it, and nobody should treat any one origin story as settled. Sausage and peppers, red-sauce pasta, Italian ice and the Sunday dinner are other parts of the same tradition. Not all of these dishes began on the Near West Side, but the neighborhood was where much of the food knowledge was concentrated, and it spread outward as families moved to other parts of the city and the suburbs.
What the numbers imply
The 1927 count adds up to 997 food businesses (500 groceries, 257 restaurants and 240 pastry shops). Set that against the 73,960 Italian-born residents the city counted at the 1930 peak, a nearby year, and the ratio comes to about one food business for every 74 Italian-born residents, before counting their American-born children. Many of those shops were tiny, run by a family out of the front room of the building they lived in. The calculation is rough, but it shows why the food trades were the entry point of an immigrant economy. A grocery or a bakery needed little capital, a known recipe and relatives to work the counter.
Two forces that rebuilt the neighborhood
Two public projects remade the Near West Side in the middle of the twentieth century. The first was the expressway system. Chicago's expressways were cut through dense neighborhoods in the 1950s and 1960s, and Holy Guardian Angel, the first Italian parish in the city, was among the buildings demolished for them. The second was the university campus, which came a few years later and is described below. Between them the two projects took out churches, homes and storefronts and scattered a population that had taken seventy years to build. The history of the road building is in how the expressways were built.
What the university took
The 1960s changed the neighborhood completely. In 1963 the Hull-House trustees accepted an offer of $875,000 for the settlement's land, and the University of Illinois built its Chicago campus in the neighborhood in the decade that followed. The construction displaced about 5,000 residents. It bulldozed about 200 businesses and 800 homes. The Italian population of the Near West Side, which had peaked in the 1950s and 1960s, began to fall soon after the 1963 decision. Some of the surviving Hull House buildings were preserved and are now a museum on the campus.
The displacement did not fall only on Italians. The Mexican families who had settled on the Near West Side moved south and west into Pilsen and Little Village, a shift described in Mexican Chicago's food streets: Pilsen and Little Village. The people who left carried their food habits to their new neighborhoods, and the city's Italian and Mexican food traditions both spread across the Southwest and West sides as a result.
Little Italy today
Taylor Street still feels like a neighborhood with a past, and that past is part of the draw. The street is lined with restaurants, bakeries and cafes that look back to the immigrant era, and the shrine and the parish buildings still anchor its southern edge. The neighborhood is also a place where students, hospital workers and young professionals live now, and the housing around it has changed. The old public housing, the ABLA Homes, was demolished in stages in the early 2000s and has been redeveloped as a mixed-income community called Roosevelt Square. Home values in the area rose sharply from 1990 to 2000, a sign of how much the neighborhood's market had shifted.
Some of that change is controversial, and some of it is simply what happens to a neighborhood next to a campus and a medical district. What survives is a street that remembers, with its family-run places and parish clubs, an economy that fed several generations of arrivals.
The city's own part in keeping the memory alive runs through its cultural programs. The Department of Cultural Affairs and Special Events runs the city's festival calendar and a public art program, described in Chicago Department of Cultural Affairs and Special Events, and Italian-American community groups run their own events through the year.
Visiting
- Getting there. Take the Blue Line to UIC-Halsted and walk south and west to Taylor Street. Riding the CTA with Ventra covers fares and passes.
- What to see. Walk Taylor Street from Halsted west to Ashland, noting the parish buildings and the shop fronts. The Jane Addams Hull-House Museum on the university campus preserves two of the settlement's original buildings and is worth a stop on the same trip.
- The Heart of Italy. For a different Italian Chicago, walk South Oakley Avenue around 24th Street, where a smaller strip keeps an older style of corner store.
- Order of operations. Walk first, eat second. The history is in the street grid and the church steeples, and the food goes down better when you know who built the block.