Blog
Milwaukee up the lake
Chicago and Milwaukee are lakefront cities about 90 miles apart; how they compare, and how Metra, Amtrak and the interstate carry people between them.
Chicago's Metra system ends at a Wisconsin town, and that is no accident. The Union Pacific North line runs up the lake from Ogilvie Transportation Center through Evanston and the North Shore, across the state line and into Kenosha, where the commuter railroad runs out of track. A little farther north, about 90 miles from the Loop, lies Milwaukee, the other great city on the western shore of Lake Michigan. People in each city know the other well enough to joke about it, and the two have been compared since the nineteenth century, when both were grain ports, railroad hubs and magnets for German, Polish and Scandinavian immigrants.
Nobody is trying to rank them here. Chicago is a metropolis of the first rank and Milwaukee is a smaller city with a distinct character, and the useful question is how they differ and what a Chicagoan or visitor should know before heading north.
Two lakefronts, two rivers
Both cities exist because of a river mouth. Chicago grew where the Chicago River met the lake; Milwaukee grew where three rivers, the Milwaukee, the Menomonee and the Kinnickinnic, join before reaching the lake. Each city turned its river into a working harbor and then, in the twentieth century, into something to look at. Chicago's version is the Riverwalk, which The Chicago River from the Riverwalk walks through, along a river that Chicago engineers famously reversed in 1900 so that it flows away from the lake. Reversing the river: the Sanitary and Ship Canal tells that story, and it is one Milwaukee never had to tell, because its rivers still run into the lake.
The lakefronts are different in scale and in plan. Chicago's shoreline is public parkland for most of its length, with a Park District that manages about 26 miles of it, and a trail that runs the length of the city; The Lakefront Trail from end to end covers the route. Milwaukee's lakefront is shorter and more compact, with a lakeside park system that includes parks designed by the Olmsted firm and a downtown art museum whose winged glass pavilion, a design by Santiago Calatrava, has become the city's picture postcard. Chicago has the Bean and Millennium Park; Milwaukee has its art museum and an annual summer music festival on the lake that is one of the largest in the country.
How Chicago pulled ahead
In the 1840s the two ports were closer in size than they are now, and Milwaukee's backers had good reason to think their town might win. Both shipped Midwestern grain east across the lakes. What separated them was what lay behind the harbor. Chicago was the point where the Great Lakes met the Mississippi system: the Illinois and Michigan Canal opened in 1848, linking the lake to the Illinois River, and in the same year the Galena and Chicago Union Railroad, the city's first rail line, was completed. Within a few years the railroads that converged on Chicago made it the place where grain, lumber and livestock from the whole interior changed hands. Milwaukee became a major regional port and manufacturing city, but it never became the national junction that Chicago did.
The two cities took different political paths afterward. Milwaukee elected Socialist mayors for much of the first half of the twentieth century, including a long run of municipal reformers whose critics called their approach "sewer socialism" for its focus on public works and clean administration. Chicago's twentieth century belonged to the machine politics of the Daley years, which The Daley years, 1955 to 1976 describes. Those are different histories, and they help explain why the two city halls feel so different today.
Size, politics and scale
The two cities govern themselves differently, which shows up in how a resident deals with city hall. Chicago has 50 wards, one alderperson each, and a City Council that meets in a chamber at 121 N. LaSalle Street; fifty wards, fifty alderpersons: how a ward works shows how that system works day to day. Milwaukee has a much smaller common council, with 15 members. Both cities answer to strong state governments, in Springfield and in Madison, that set the limits on what a city can tax and regulate.
In scale, Chicago is the third largest city in the United States, and Milwaukee is a mid-sized city by comparison. That difference shapes almost everything about a visit. Chicago's neighborhoods stretch for miles and its transit system is a major piece of regional infrastructure; Milwaukee's downtown, its Third Ward warehouse district, its lakefront and its older neighborhoods can all be reached in a day without a long ride. A trip from Chicago to Milwaukee is a short-distance trip to a smaller place, and many visitors find that this is the appeal.
Beer, brick and neighborhoods
German immigrants shaped both cities, but Milwaukee's brewing industry made the city's name. For a century and a half, brewing was Milwaukee's identity, and its architecture still shows it: the cream-colored brick that was fired from local clay gave the city a nickname, the "Cream City," and many older buildings use it. Chicago has its own brewing history, which chicago's beer history from the 1830s to craft describes, but Chicago was never the beer capital that Milwaukee was.
Both cities have long Polish, German and Scandinavian histories, and both have dishes tied to those histories. In Chicago, The Maxwell Street Polish and the old market describes how the city's Polish sausage tradition took hold at an open-air market on the Near West Side. Milwaukee has its own sausage and custard traditions, and fish fries on Friday nights are a regional institution in Wisconsin. A Chicagoan on a first visit will recognize the corner taverns and neighborhood churches, packed into a tighter space.
Sports and the Bears-Packers line
The sports rivalry between the two cities is mostly friendly. Milwaukee's baseball team, the Brewers, and Chicago's Cubs have a rivalry that peaks on summer weekends when Chicagoans drive north to the ballpark or Wisconsinites drive south to Wrigley Field. The more serious rivalry is football: the Bears and the Green Bay Packers have been playing each other since 1921, making them one of the oldest rivalries in professional football, and the Packers' home is in Green Bay, in Wisconsin. Milwaukee's basketball team, the Bucks, plays in a downtown arena. Chicago's equivalents are described in Wrigley Field from Weeghman Park to today and The United Center: from Chicago Stadium to the West Side arena.
Four ways up the lake
There are four ways to make the trip, and they are very different.
- Amtrak's Hiawatha Service. An Amtrak route of about 86 miles runs between Chicago Union Station and downtown Milwaukee with intermediate stops that include Glenview and, on the Wisconsin side, Milwaukee's airport. The trip takes about an hour and a half end to end, and the train runs several times a day, including Sundays. Check Amtrak's current schedule and fares. Union Station and Amtrak's Midwest hub describes the Chicago terminal.
- Metra to Kenosha. Metra's Union Pacific North line ends at Kenosha, which is in Wisconsin but short of Milwaukee. It gets you to Kenosha, and from there Milwaukee is not reached by commuter rail. metra for first-time riders covers how to buy and use a ticket, and Four downtown Metra terminals compared explains why the line begins at Ogilvie Transportation Center.
- By road. The drive is I-94 north, which runs through the Illinois Tollway system as the Tri-State Tollway before it crosses the state line. Delays are most common at the toll plazas and approaching Milwaukee at the end of a weekend.
- By bus. Intercity buses run between the cities on the same interstate. Check the current carrier schedules.
Pair this with A weekend in Chicago by transit alone if you are planning a longer visit that begins or ends in Chicago.
From the city's north end
If you are in Rogers Park, the city's northernmost lakefront neighborhood, which Rogers Park describes, you are closer to Milwaukee than almost any other Chicagoan is. The Metra line that serves Rogers Park and Evanston is the one that carries on to Kenosha.
A day in each direction
A Chicagoan going north has an easy day if the plan is modest. Take the morning Hiawatha, walk from the downtown station to the lakefront, spend a few hours at the art museum and the riverfront, and take an evening train back; the lake is the thread that ties the day together, and the pace is slower than a day in the Loop. A Milwaukeean coming south should plan the opposite: pick one neighborhood or one cluster of institutions and resist the urge to cover the city. The Museum Campus: Field Museum, Shedd Aquarium and Adler Planetarium and A walk under the Loop elevated, block by block are two ways to organize a first day.
Both cities also look different in winter. Lake Michigan holds heat into the early winter and cools the air in spring, and both cities live with lake-effect weather, long gray stretches in January and the same habit of planning around the forecast. when the cold becomes dangerous: extreme cold and the city's response covers what the extreme cold looks like on the Chicago side. A visit in summer is the easier choice for a first trip north, when festival season fills the Milwaukee lakefront and the Chicago lakefront at the same time.
What you will notice
A Chicagoan arriving will notice how compact the downtown is and how close the lake and the older neighborhoods are to it. A visitor from Milwaukee coming south will notice the opposite: how large Chicago is, and how quickly the downtown gives way to dozens of other neighborhoods. Both cities share a Great Lakes climate, a skyline of brick and glass and a history of immigrant neighborhoods and heavy industry. They also share the lake, and with it the habit of using "the lake" as a compass: east is the water, and everything else is "inland."