Blog

Two disasters: the Iroquois Theater fire and the Eastland

A matinee fire in 1903 killed 602 and a steamer rolled over at its river dock in 1915, killing 844. What went wrong each time and what changed afterward.

Twelve years apart, two disasters in downtown Chicago killed more than 1,400 people between them, most in a few minutes, and neither one was a war, a storm or an act of nature. A theater fire on the afternoon of December 30, 1903 killed 602. A steamship that rolled over while tied to its dock on July 24, 1915 killed 844. Both involved crowds out to enjoy themselves: families at a holiday matinee, factory workers and their relatives heading out for a company picnic. Both were preventable, and both changed how buildings and boats are regulated. Here is what each involved, side by side.

The Iroquois Theatre

The Iroquois Theatre, at 26 West Randolph Street, had opened on November 23, 1903, barely five weeks before the fire. It was advertised as "absolutely fireproof." It held 1,602 people across three levels, and on the afternoon of Wednesday, December 30 it was playing a matinee of Mr. Blue Beard, a holiday musical starring the comedian Eddie Foy. Estimates of the crowd run from about 1,700 to more than 2,100, and a great many of the people in the seats were children, home from school for the holidays.

The fire

At about 3:15 in the afternoon an arc lamp on stage broke, and the sparks lit muslin curtains. Stagehands tried to put it out and could not. The theater had a safety curtain meant to be lowered across the stage opening to wall off the auditorium from a fire on stage. It was described as asbestos, but a later analysis found it was largely wood pulp, and in any case it snagged on a light reflector and never came all the way down. Skylights above the stage that might have vented smoke and flames had been fastened shut. Flames swept toward the audience.

The exits

The building had far fewer working exits than its size called for. Some doors opened inward. Some had latches that few people could work in the dark and the crush. Exit signs and emergency lighting were missing, and some exits were hidden behind drapery. Iron gates blocked some of the secondary stairways. Fire escapes were icy and narrow, and one was installed improperly. The theater had no sprinklers or alarms, and no fire-alarm box or telephone inside it. Reports differ on the exact count of exits, with figures of 30 and 25 cited, and press accounts said fewer than half a dozen worked.

About 575 people died on the day, and at least 30 more died later of their injuries, for a total of 602. Roughly 250 were injured.

The aftermath

On January 1, 1904 the lessees of the theater, Will J. Davis and Harry Powers, and the city's building commissioner, George Williams, were arrested on manslaughter charges. Davis was acquitted, and most of the charges against the others were dismissed some three years later. Chicago closed all its theaters for six weeks. The disaster damaged the political standing of the mayor.

The reforms that followed shaped the way public buildings are built today. Panic bars, the push-bars that open a door under pressure from a crowd, became widespread. Exit doors were required to open outward and to be clearly marked. Outward-opening doors did not become standard nationwide until after the Collinwood School fire of 1908 in Ohio. The memorials include the Iroquois Memorial Hospital, built to honor the dead, and a bronze memorial by Lorado Taft, rededicated in 2010. For years the city held a memorial service each December at City Hall.

The Iroquois did not last long as a theater. It reopened as Hyde & Behman's Music Hall in 1904 and later as the Colonial Theatre, and was demolished in 1925. The Oriental Theatre was built on the site in 1926, and renamed the Nederlander Theatre in 2019. The theatre district is described in The theater buildings of Uptown and the Loop.

The Eastland

The Eastland was a Great Lakes passenger steamer, built in 1903 in Port Huron, Michigan, and nicknamed the "Greyhound of the Lakes" for her speed. She had a problem from the start: modifications after her launch put weight high in the hull, which made her top-heavy. She had scares in 1904 and 1912, when she nearly capsized, and the ship was known to be tender. In 1914 the St. Joseph-Chicago Steamship Company bought her and added concrete flooring, which put her weight up again.

The picnic

On the morning of July 24, 1915, the Eastland was moored at a dock on the Chicago River, loading employees of the Western Electric Company, many of them with families, for an annual picnic across the lake in Michigan City, Indiana. The employees came from the company's Hawthorne Works. A new federal law passed that year required more lifeboats on passenger ships, and the extra lifeboats added still more weight above the waterline.

Roughly 2,500 people crowded aboard, many of them below deck, and the ship began to list. She rolled onto her side while still tied up, in calm water, and the people below were trapped. The disaster killed 844 people.

The rescue

Rescue began at once. The crews of nearby vessels, including a boat called the Kenosha, pulled alongside the capsized hull and hauled out passengers, and a nurse named Helen Repa coordinated much of the work on the scene. The number of dead overwhelmed the city's usual arrangements, and bodies were taken to temporary morgues.

The aftermath

A grand jury indicted company officers for manslaughter, and the captain and the engineer for criminal carelessness. A request from Illinois to extradite defendants from Michigan was refused for lack of sufficient evidence. The ship herself was raised, sold to the Navy and converted into a gunboat, the USS Wilmette, which trained reservists on the Great Lakes until she was scrapped in 1947.

The disaster has been remembered less loudly than the Iroquois fire, though in recent decades it has drawn more attention: a riverside marker in 1989, since replaced, a ship-wheel memorial at Bohemian National Cemetery in 2015, and a number of plays, a television episode and other works. The river where it happened is described in The Chicago River from the Riverwalk.

Side by side

Iroquois Theatre Eastland
Date December 30, 1903 July 24, 1915
Place 26 W. Randolph Street A dock on the Chicago River
Deaths 602 844
Occasion Holiday matinee Employee picnic outing
Trigger A broken arc lamp ignited curtains Top-heavy ship rolled while tied up
Failures Exits, curtain, alarms, skylights Stability, added weight, loading
Prosecutions Manslaughter charges; Davis acquitted, others dismissed Indictments; extradition refused
Changes Panic bars, outward-opening doors, clear exits Greater scrutiny of ship stability

What each changed

The Iroquois fire led straight to rules every American theater now follows. The principles are simple: exits must be enough in number and in width, doors must open outward, exit signs must be visible and the way out must be clear. Modern Chicago enforces them through inspections by the Department of Buildings (Chicago Department of Buildings) and by the fire department (Chicago Fire Department). The Eastland is a case of a safety measure that made a boat less safe: lifeboats meant to protect passengers added weight to a ship already prone to roll.

A checklist drawn from both

The failures at the Iroquois and on the Eastland boil down to a short checklist still worth running through in any crowded place, whether a theater, an arena, a ferry or a street festival:

  1. Find two ways out when you arrive, not just the one you came in by.
  2. Notice whether the exit signs are lit and the doors are unobstructed. At the Iroquois, signs were missing and some exits were hidden behind drapery.
  3. Look for the safety equipment. Sprinklers, alarms and a working way to call for help were all absent in 1903.
  4. On a boat, look at where people are standing. The Eastland rolled when thousands of passengers shifted on a ship that was already too heavy above the waterline.
  5. If something starts, move early and calmly. In both disasters the minutes that mattered were the first ones.

None of this replaces the inspections cities carry out, but it shows how the inspection rules came about: through disasters in which the people inside could not get out.

The two disasters in the city's memory

The Iroquois fire changed the city fast. All theaters closed for six weeks, the arrests and trials followed within days, and the rules about exits and doors were rewritten. The Eastland has been remembered more quietly. Its memorials came later: a riverside marker in 1989, a ship-wheel memorial at Bohemian National Cemetery in 2015 and a growing number of books and performances. The victims were employees of the Western Electric Company and their families, and descendants and historians carry the story on.

Questions people ask

Was the Iroquois really fireproof? It was advertised that way. In fact it lacked sprinklers, alarms and working exits, and the safety curtain failed.

How many people died? 602 in the Iroquois fire, including about 575 on the day itself and at least 30 later, and 844 in the Eastland capsizing.

Were people held responsible? Charges were brought in both cases. The theater's lessee was acquitted and most other charges dismissed, and in the Eastland case a grand jury indicted company officers, the captain and the engineer, though an extradition request was refused for lack of sufficient evidence.

Can I see the site of the theater? The Oriental Theatre, renamed the Nederlander in 2019, stands on the site in the theater district. The Eastland disaster took place in the river downtown, and the ship's later life as a Navy gunboat is part of the story told at memorial events.

A note for readers today

Both tragedies were, first, about crowds. A building or a boat that is safe at half its capacity can be deadly at full capacity, and the rules that protect people are rules about limits: how many, how wide, how fast out. Those are the questions fire inspectors and building officials still ask, and the city's emergency agencies are described at Office of Emergency Management and Communications. For the practical steps a resident can take, see Emergency preparedness in Chicago.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic