Blog
Chicago's coffee culture without the lists
Why Chicago neighborhoods use cafes as meeting places, from the 1893 Hull-House coffee house to Wicker Park, Andersonville and Hyde Park. No names, no rankings.
Every few months somebody publishes a new list of "the best coffee in Chicago," and every few months the list starts an argument nobody can win. Not here. This piece names no cafe and ranks nothing. What it describes is something true in nearly every neighborhood of the city: the coffee shop is one of the places where Chicago's neighborhoods actually gather. Why it got that way, and how the cafes in different parts of town differ, are more interesting than any ranking, and they say something about how the city lives.
The idea of a third place
Sociologists have a phrase, "third place," for a spot that is neither home nor work, where people meet informally and regularly. It comes from the sociologist Ray Oldenburg's 1989 book The Great Good Place. A neighborhood tavern, a barbershop, a diner and a park bench are all third places, and so is a cafe. They matter because anybody can walk in, they cost very little, and a regular can show up without an invitation and find someone to talk to.
Chicago is a city of neighborhoods, and each neighborhood has had its own third places as long as there has been a city. The tavern was the big one for a century or more. The cafe is the newer arrival, and in a lot of the city it has taken over some of the tavern's daytime work: a place to read, meet, write and wait. A cafe that stays open through the afternoon becomes a kind of public room.
An older coffee house
The first public experiment with a neighborhood coffee house in Chicago was not a business at all. In 1893 Hull-House, the settlement on the Near West Side that Jane Addams and Ellen Gates Starr founded in 1889, opened a coffee house and gymnasium as part of its growing complex. It served hot coffee, soup, stew and rolls to workers and families in a neighborhood of immigrants from many countries. It was part of the settlement's wider mission, described in Hull House and the settlement movement: to give neighbors a place to eat, learn and meet.
The lesson of that early example is that a coffee house in Chicago has long been understood as a social service as much as a place to buy a drink. The idea lives on in a thousand informal forms, from the church basement coffee hour to the corner cafe where the same people sit at the same tables.
Coffee traditions that came with immigrants
The city's cafe culture is layered. Each group that came to Chicago brought its own way of drinking coffee and its own idea of how to share it.
- Swedish. Andersonville, on the North Side along Clark Street, has Swedish roots that go back to the nineteenth century, and the Swedish tradition of fika, a break for coffee and something sweet taken with others, is part of the neighborhood's story. The Swedish American Museum, which opened in 1976 at 5211 N. Clark Street, preserves that history. The neighborhood has since drawn many other groups, and its cafes reflect all of them.
- Italian. Little Italy and the older Italian neighborhoods brought the espresso bar, where a small, strong coffee gets drunk fast at the counter. The history is in Italian-American Chicago: Little Italy and the Near West Side.
- Mexican. Mexican households and bakeries serve coffee beside pan dulce, sometimes brewed with cinnamon and unrefined sugar in the style called café de olla. The panaderías of Pilsen and Little Village, covered in Mexican Chicago's food streets: Pilsen and Little Village, are the place to see it.
- Polish, Czech and German. The neighborhoods these groups settled had their own bakery and coffee habits, with filled pastries, coffee cakes and a mid-afternoon coffee.
None of these traditions pushed out the others. They sit side by side, and a neighborhood's cafe will often show you which groups arrived and when.
Three kinds of neighborhood cafe
Different neighborhoods use cafes in different ways. These are not rankings. They are three ways a neighborhood can work.
Wicker Park and the Near Northwest Side. Wicker Park has long had a creative and artistic reputation, and the cafes around Milwaukee, Damen and North avenues have served as meeting places for writers, musicians and designers. With its Blue Line stations and busy street grid, the neighborhood is a place where people pass through all day, and the cafe is a good spot to wait for a friend or finish a project. The neighborhood is described in Wicker Park and Bucktown and Wicker Park and its six-way intersection.
Andersonville. On Clark Street the cafe belongs to a neighborhood of small, independent shops, and the strip keeps a village feel. The rhythm is residential. People walk to it in the morning and mid-afternoon, and the same faces turn up at the same tables. The history of the neighborhood and the community around it is in edgewater: the last community area added, since the two are neighbors.
Hyde Park. On the South Side, the University of Chicago shapes the neighborhood's cafe life. Students, faculty and residents all use cafes to read and talk, and the academic calendar drives the traffic: busy in the weeks of the term, quiet in the long breaks. The neighborhood is described in Hyde Park, and the university in The University of Chicago on the Midway.
What a cafe does for a neighborhood
A good cafe does several things at once.
- It gives people a reason to be on the street. A busy cafe puts people on the sidewalk, which supports the businesses around it.
- It is an inexpensive way to spend time. One cup buys a table for a morning, in a city where renting a room costs far more.
- It is a workplace. Many people who work remotely or freelance use cafes as an office, and the daytime laptop crowd has become one of the defining features of the modern cafe.
- It is a meeting place that costs nothing to join. Anyone can come in, and the barista knows the regulars.
The flip side is that a table is limited. A cafe has only so many seats, and the unspoken rules of the room, such as not taking a four-top alone at the lunch rush, are what keep it working for everybody. Most cafes manage it by courtesy.
A short vocabulary
Cafe menus use a handful of terms, and knowing them makes any board in any neighborhood easier to read.
- Drip or batch brew. Coffee brewed in a large batch and poured to order, the fastest and cheapest option.
- Espresso. A small, concentrated shot made by forcing hot water through finely ground coffee under pressure. It is the base of most other drinks.
- Americano. Espresso diluted with hot water, closer to drip coffee in strength.
- Latte and cappuccino. Espresso with steamed milk; a cappuccino has more foam and less milk, and a latte has more milk.
- Pour-over. Coffee brewed one cup at a time by pouring hot water over grounds in a filter, slower and usually more expensive than batch brew.
- Cold brew. Coffee steeped in cold water for many hours, served over ice, a favorite in the Chicago summer.
None of this needs a ranking. The cheapest cup and the fanciest one both do the job of buying a seat.
An afternoon at a cafe, with the arithmetic
Say a freelancer settles in for four hours on a weekday. For the example, suppose a drip coffee costs $3.50 and a pastry $4.00, and the freelancer buys a coffee on arrival, a second coffee two hours later and a pastry at lunchtime. The spending is:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Two drip coffees at $3.50 | $7.00 |
| One pastry at $4.00 | $4.00 |
| Total before tax and tip | $11.00 |
Four hours at $11.00 comes to $2.75 an hour, less than the hourly cost of almost any rented desk. The numbers are invented, but the structure is why the cafe works as an office for so many people, and why cafe owners think hard about how long a customer stays and how much a table earns. A good rule on both sides of the counter: the longer you stay, the more you buy. It is a courtesy, and it is part of how a neighborhood keeps its cafes.
The library as the other third place
The cafe is not the only public room in town that welcomes somebody with a book or a laptop. The Chicago Public Library has 81 locations, from the main Harold Washington Library Center at 400 S. State Street to the neighborhood branches, and a library card is free for residents. A library offers what a cafe cannot: quiet, shelves, public computers and no purchase required. Readers who want a place to work can use either, and many use both. The library system is described in Chicago Public Library, and the process of getting a card is in Getting and using a Chicago Public Library card.
How cafes are licensed
A cafe is a food business like any other. It needs a business license from the Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection, it is subject to inspection by the Department of Public Health, and a cafe that wants to put tables on the sidewalk needs a permit for use of the public way. The agencies and their roles are described in Chicago Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection. The public inspection record of a cafe, like that of a restaurant, can be looked up on the city's data portal, as explained in Reading a Chicago restaurant inspection report.
Coffee and the seasons
The cafe year follows the weather. In the Chicago winter, with a January average of about 26 degrees, a warm room and a hot drink are a refuge, and the cafes fill early and stay full. In summer, iced drinks and patios take over. The hours of the day matter, too: the morning commuter rush, especially near train stations, gives way to the late-morning laptop crowd, a lunch lull and a mid-afternoon wave of students and parents with children.
If you want to understand a Chicago neighborhood, sit in its cafe for an hour on a Saturday morning, with whatever you like to drink, and watch who comes in. The residents, the language they use, the stroller traffic and the laptop traffic, and the way the staff greets the regulars tell you more about the street than any list does.