Blog

Comedy and improv as a Chicago export

How improvisational theater grew from a Hyde Park bar in 1955 and a Wells Street revue in 1959 into a form taught around the world, and how to try it yourself.

A stage, a chair or two, no script, no set. Two people walk out. One says a line, the other answers, and thirty seconds later a room of strangers is laughing at a situation that did not exist a minute ago and never will again. That is improvisational theater, and for a form with a reputation for being made up on the spot, it has a remarkably precise paper trail. It was worked out, rule by rule and show by show, in Chicago in the second half of the twentieth century, and the city has been shipping it out ever since, in the form of teachers, techniques and the performers who learned from them. What follows is a short history built from the dates and names on record, and a guide to catching it yourself.

A bar in Hyde Park

It starts in 1955. That summer a group of University of Chicago students, led by David Shepherd and Paul Sills, formed a company called the Compass Players in a Hyde Park bar. The idea was to give a neighborhood crowd a theater that answered the moment: short scenes, made up from a suggestion or a situation, played for people who had come for a drink as much as for a show. The Compass Players are described as among the first organized improv troupes in Chicago, and many of the rules of comedic improvisation that performers still use were first formalized in the late 1950s and early 1960s, among the Compass Players. Elaine May was central to developing the troupe's improvisational premises.

Behind the Compass stood a teacher. Viola Spolin, the mother of Paul Sills, had developed a set of exercises, which she called theater games, meant to teach performers to listen and respond. They later became known as Theater Games, and they shaped how the first generation of modern American improvisers worked. Spolin is the reason improv gets taught as a discipline with exercises and not just practiced as a knack.

The Hyde Park neighborhood where it began is described in Hyde Park, and the university that supplied the group's first members is the subject of The University of Chicago on the Midway.

A revue on Wells Street

When the Compass Players broke up, Paul Sills carried the method into a new company. The Second City opened on December 16, 1959, with a revue at 1842 North Wells Street. Its founders were Paul Sills, Bernard Sahlins and Howard Alk. The format was a cabaret revue: scenes built through improvisation, then shaped and repeated, often needling social conventions, political figures and events. Spolin trained new performers there through classes and exercises, which became the cornerstone of modern improv training.

Since 1967 the theater has been at 1616 North Wells Street, in Old Town. It is described as the oldest improvisational theater troupe to be continuously based in Chicago. The neighborhood is covered in Old Town: Victorian Chicago that survived the fire and Old Town.

From the mid-1980s the company also ran a training center, with locations in Chicago, Toronto and Los Angeles, and the Chicago center now has over 5,000 students. A film school was added in 2016, and the company has opened theaters and programs outside Chicago, including one in New York that opened in Brooklyn on November 16, 2023. What began as a single room grew into a teaching institution.

The first schools

The method spread through classrooms as much as stages. In the mid-1960s, Spolin's classes passed to Jo Forsberg, who developed them into a one-year course that became The Players Workshop, described as the first official improv school in the United States. The notion that improvisation could be taught, in a sequence of lessons with a final performance, was born in Chicago, and it is the basis of what most improv students run into today.

Longform and the Harold

The next big change was in the form. The early Compass and Second City work was built from short scenes. A new school of thought in Chicago turned toward longer pieces that grow out of a single suggestion and weave several scenes together. ImprovOlympic, later known as iO, was created by Charna Halpern with Del Close, and it was devoted to a longform format called the Harold, created by Close. At iO, the Harold was combined with a technique called the Time Dash, from David Shepherd, and the revised version became the basis for modern longform improv. The Annoyance Theatre, founded in Chicago in 1987, was another club emphasizing longform improv, and it later expanded to multiple locations in Chicago and New York.

Over the second half of the century, Chicago became the place where improv was both performed and taught, with companies and schools offering different philosophies. The result is a scene with a long lineage and a lot of argument inside it.

A timeline

Date Event
Summer 1955 The Compass Players form in a Hyde Park bar
December 16, 1959 The Second City's first revue opens at 1842 North Wells Street
Mid-1960s Jo Forsberg develops the Players Workshop, the first official improv school in the U.S.
1967 The Second City settles at 1616 North Wells Street
Mid-1980s The Second City Training Center is founded
1987 The Annoyance Theatre is founded in Chicago
2016 The Second City adds a film school
November 16, 2023 The Second City's New York location opens in Brooklyn

How improv works

Improv looks like chaos. It runs on a few principles that performers learn early.

  1. Listen. The most important skill is paying attention to what a scene partner just did. This is the heart of Spolin's exercises.
  2. Accept the offer. Whatever a partner establishes, whether a place, a relationship or a problem, becomes true on stage. Teachers often phrase this as agreeing and adding something of your own.
  3. Commit. A scene works when performers play it for real. Hesitation reads as doubt, and doubt kills laughter.
  4. Serve the scene, not yourself. A performer who tries to be funny at a partner's expense tends to lose the audience. The best moments come from reacting honestly.
  5. Embrace mistakes. An error is one more piece of information to use.

These principles are why improv training caught on outside the theater, in business and teaching as well; a form that teaches people to listen and adapt has uses beyond comedy.

Words on the poster

Improv listings speak their own dialect, and a short glossary helps.

  • Shortform. Brief games with a clear rule or structure, often driven by audience suggestions. The Compass and early Second City work leaned this way.
  • Longform. A sustained piece, often twenty minutes or more, that weaves scenes together from one suggestion. The Harold is the best-known structure.
  • Suggestion. A word or idea from the audience that starts the show.
  • Set. One performance by a group or team.
  • Revue. A show of scenes, often sketches shaped from improvisation, like the first Second City program.
  • Troupe or ensemble. The group of performers who work together regularly.

A small exercise to try

Spolin's theater games were built for amateurs, and a simple version needs only two people. Stand facing a partner and decide who leads. The leader moves slowly, and the partner mirrors as closely as possible, so an observer could not tell who is leading. After a minute, switch, and after another minute, let the leadership pass back and forth without a signal. The exercise trains the skill all improv rests on: close attention to another person. It is a quick way to see why the form asks for listening before wit.

Why Chicago

Fair question: why here, and not New York or Los Angeles? One thing is clear from the record. Chicago had a university whose students were willing to experiment, a neighborhood with bars and small stages, and a teacher with a method to hand them. Past that, the usual explanations, a culture often described as unpretentious, a city with room for small companies to try things, are impressions, not findings, though they fit what happened.

The city's cultural department runs festivals and venues, offers grants for artists and publishes event listings, and its programs are described in Chicago Department of Cultural Affairs and Special Events.

How to try it

A visitor who wants improv in Chicago has plenty of options, and the easiest way to choose is to decide how you want to take part.

  • Watch a show. The Second City's revues at 1616 North Wells Street are the classic starting point, and the theater's own site lists what is playing and the ticket prices. Longform shows are staged at the companies that grew from the iO and Annoyance traditions, and each publishes its own schedule.
  • Take a class. The Second City Training Center in Chicago has over 5,000 students, and other schools offer introductory classes. A first class is generally a series of games, not a performance.
  • Try a smaller stage. Companies across the city publish their own schedules, and ticket prices vary by venue.
  • Bring someone. Improv is a social form, and it is funnier in a group.

Remember that improv is live, so every show is different. The shows that look polished in a theater were built over hundreds of hours of practice, and the polish is what lets the improvisers look unprepared.

The export

The striking part is how far it has traveled. Techniques first worked out in Chicago rooms are now taught in schools and companies in many countries, and the Second City has opened outposts in other cities. But the roots are local: a bar in Hyde Park, a street in Old Town, a few teachers and a very large number of students. That is a fair description of how much of Chicago's culture gets made, and the district it came from is worth a visit. For a month-by-month view of what else the city offers, see chicago month by month.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic