Blog

Old Town: Victorian Chicago that survived the fire

Cabbage fields, a Bavarian church that outlasted 1871, a folk-music school and a comedy theater: how Old Town got its Victorian blocks and why they were saved.

Ask an old-timer where Old Town ends and he will cock his head and tell you it ends where you can't hear the bells of St. Michael's anymore. He means it, more or less. The neighborhood has no official boundary in city law, and the community areas it spans, the Near North Side and Lincoln Park, are administrative units that cut right through it. The tower is what Chicagoans carry in their minds: a Bavarian-built church that is one of seven buildings within the fire's burned area to have come through the Great Chicago Fire of 1871. Around it stand the cottages and townhouses that went up in the year after the fire.

Old Town at a glance

Where Between the Gold Coast and Lincoln Park, across parts of the Near North Side and Lincoln Park community areas
Borders None in law; one tradition says the neighborhood reaches as far as the bells of St. Michael's Church can be heard
Protected The Old Town Triangle Historic District, a Chicago Landmark since September 28, 1977 and on the National Register since November 8, 1984
Known for Victorian houses built just after the 1871 fire, St. Michael's Church, folk music, comedy and the Old Town Art Fair

Cabbage fields and a ridge

Before it was a neighborhood, this part of the North Side was farmland. In the nineteenth century, German and Luxembourgish immigrants farmed the marshy ground north of North Avenue, growing vegetables for the city, and the district was nicknamed "the Cabbage Patch." Clark Street, the main street along its western side, follows an old road that ran along a low ridge near Lake Michigan, one of the few patches of firm ground in the area. The immigrants built a church, St. Michael's, which became the center of the German community.

The Great Chicago Fire reached this area in October 1871. The fire destroyed about 17,000 structures across 3.3 square miles over two days, killed about 300 people and left more than 100,000 homeless; the story is told hour by hour in The Great Chicago Fire of 1871, night by night. St. Michael's survived the fire, and the church stands today. It is among the few structures from before the fire still in use, and the group of those survivors is covered in The buildings that survived the Great Fire.

The houses of 1872

What gives Old Town its look is the rebuilding that followed. After the fire, many of the workers and craftspeople who lost their homes rebuilt here fast. The streets of the Old Town Triangle, the heart of the district, are lined with modest Italianate and Queen Anne houses built in 1872 and the years that followed: narrow frame and brick cottages, two-story row houses and small townhouses with bay windows, carved wooden trim and steep front steps. They were homes for working families, with small yards and gardens, not mansions.

The modest scale is the whole point. The Gold Coast, a few blocks to the south, kept the mansions of the wealthy, and The Gold Coast Historic District on foot describes it. Old Town kept the houses of ordinary families, and the contrast between the two is the reason both are worth seeing. Old Town's historic district was designated a Chicago Landmark on September 28, 1977 and was added to the National Register of Historic Places on November 8, 1984. The designations help guard against demolition and require review of exterior changes under the city's landmark rules, administered through the Department of Planning and Development; see Chicago Department of Planning and Development.

Who lived here

The people of Old Town changed several times, and each wave left something behind.

  • Germans and Luxembourgers built the first settlement and the church.
  • Puerto Ricans arrived in the 1950s. Old Town was an enclave for many of the first Puerto Ricans to settle in Chicago, a history that continued westward into the Humboldt Park area, described in Humboldt Park: the lagoon and Division Street.
  • Artists and musicians settled here in the postwar decades, drawn by cheap rents and old buildings. The Old Town Art Fair has roots in the postwar "Old Town Holiday" art fairs, and the neighborhood has held it for decades.
  • The counterculture followed in the 1960s and 1970s, when Old Town was a center of the hippie and yippie movements. Folk clubs on Wells Street hosted singer-songwriters, and the Wells Street and North Avenue area was a hub of storefront shops, coffeehouses and nightlife, including gay nightlife in the 1960s through the 1980s.
  • Later residents arrived as property values rose, and the neighborhood became more affluent, as in much of the North Side.

Music and comedy

Two institutions tie the neighborhood to the city's performing arts. The Old Town School of Folk Music opened in 1957 at 333 W. North Ave. and moved in 1968 to 909 W. Armitage Ave., and it grew into one of the best-known folk music schools in the country, with classes for children and adults. The Second City, the comedy theater founded in 1959 on Wells Street, trained generations of performers and is part of the story told in Comedy and improv as a Chicago export. Both belong to a period when Old Town was a cheap place to try new things, and both stayed even as the rents around them climbed.

Walking it

A good route starts at the corner of North Avenue and Wells Street, the old center of the nightlife district, with its mix of older storefronts and newer shops. From there:

  1. Walk north on Wells Street to see the strip that was once a row of folk clubs and is still home to the Second City.
  2. Turn east into the Old Town Triangle to look at the 1872 houses. The side streets are narrow and quiet, and the details, from the cornices to the iron fences, repay a slow walk.
  3. Find St. Michael's Church, whose tower rises over the neighborhood.
  4. Go east to the park. The neighborhood ends at Lincoln Park; the park is covered in Lincoln Park: the park and the neighborhood that share a name, and the lakefront beyond it is a short walk.
  5. Return along Clark Street, the ridge road, to see the older commercial buildings along the western edge.

The streets around the Triangle host the Old Town Art Fair, so a walk on that weekend is more crowded than usual. The rest of the year the residential blocks are quiet.

What Old Town says about the rest of the city

What does Old Town tell us about Chicago? First, that the Great Fire did not wipe the slate clean. A handful of buildings survived, and a neighborhood was rebuilt within months using the same street pattern, the same ownership and, in many cases, the same families. Second, that the city's preservation system does a different job here than it does in the Gold Coast. Where the Gold Coast protects mansions, Old Town protects a streetscape: it is the pattern of small houses on narrow lots, and the way they relate to the street, that the landmark rules are trying to keep.

Third, that neighborhoods change faster than their architecture. A district built for German vegetable farmers and their neighbors became a home for artists and then for a dense professional population, and the buildings adapted. The Victorian houses of Old Town did not turn into museum pieces; they became homes, rented rooms, studios and offices, and each generation left a layer.

A field guide to the houses

Two styles dominate the Triangle, and learning to tell them apart makes a walk more interesting.

  • Italianate. Look for tall, narrow windows with decorative hoods or arched tops, low-pitched roofs and deep eaves held up by ornamental brackets. The look borrows from Italian villas and was widely used in American towns in the middle of the nineteenth century.
  • Queen Anne. Look for asymmetry: a projecting bay, a turret or a gable on one side, varied surfaces, decorative shingles or patterned brick, and a porch. It was the fashionable style of the 1880s and 1890s.

Most of the buildings are small. A typical lot is narrow, the house sits close to the sidewalk behind a short flight of steps and an iron railing, and a back yard or garden lies behind. The scale is what visitors remember. Add the mature street trees, the lack of high-rises and the quiet side streets, and it can feel like a small town set inside a large city. The edge of the district is easy to spot: a few blocks away, the towers begin.

Getting there

Old Town is served by the Brown and Purple Lines at the Sedgwick station, near North Avenue and Sedgwick Street, and the Red Line's Clark/Division and North/Clybourn stations are within walking distance of its edges. Buses run along Clark Street, North Avenue and Wells Street. Riding the CTA with Ventra explains the fare options. Parking on the side streets is by residential permit in many blocks, and the signs state the hours; How to read a Chicago parking sign explains how to read them. Walking or transit is easier than driving for most visits.

Who saved it

Much of the credit for Old Town's survival goes to its residents. In many of the city's older neighborhoods the pressure to tear down small houses and build larger buildings came as land values climbed, and Old Town, close to the lake and downtown, was exposed to it. Residents and neighborhood groups pressed for protection, and the landmark designation of 1977 and the National Register listing of 1984 followed. The Old Town Triangle Association, a neighborhood group, has long worked on preservation and community life. The result is a district where many blocks look much as they did a century ago. It is also an example of a point that the city's preservation system comes back to again and again: a neighborhood's character can be as valuable as any single building in it.

Related city government

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic