Blog
Paying for police misconduct settlements: the borrowing proposal
The 2027 budget would borrow about $480 million for police misconduct settlements: what it pays for, how settlements are approved, and each side's case.
Of everything in the mayor's 2027 budget, one item has set off more shouting in the council chamber than the new taxes: a plan to borrow roughly $480 million, by selling bonds, to pay for settlements and judgments in lawsuits over police misconduct. Most cities pay settlements out of their operating funds. Chicago did that for years, then added debt to cover the overruns. The 2027 proposal would make borrowing the main way to pay and would put the cost into the city's long-term debt. The proposal had not been adopted as of mid-November 2026, and the council could reduce it, reject it or change it.
What the money buys
When a person sues the city alleging that police officers violated their rights, the city's Law Department defends the case, and most of the large cases are filed in federal court. A case ends one of three ways: a trial verdict, a dismissal or a settlement. Money paid after a verdict or a settlement comes from city funds, not from the individual officers.
The cases that drive the biggest payouts are lawsuits from people who were convicted of crimes and later had their convictions overturned, claiming that officers fabricated evidence or coerced statements. These suits take years to bring, because they begin only after a conviction is vacated, and they involve long prison sentences, which is why verdicts and settlements can be very large. Several of the biggest involve groups of cases that trace back to a single former officer or unit, so a single decision about one officer's record can produce dozens of lawsuits at once.
In October 2026 the council approved a global settlement of $260.8 million covering 17 plaintiffs whose cases were tied to one former detective. Reports at the time put the total cost of resolving the lawsuits tied to that detective above $470 million, with about 25 suits still pending. That is the background to the budget proposal: a large share of expected costs in the coming years is already identifiable.
How a settlement gets approved
The city does not simply write a check. A large settlement goes first to the council's Finance Committee, where aldermen hear the recommendation from the Law Department, and then to the full City Council for a vote. The council's Finance Committee backed the $260.8 million settlement before the full council approved it. Because the votes happen in public, the amount and the case name appear on a posted agenda.
Where the money comes from is the budget question. The city budgets a set amount each year for police settlements and judgments, about $82 million a year, according to a Tribune analysis reported during the 2027 budget hearings, and it has spent more than that in nearly every year since 2010. When the budgeted amount runs out, the city pays from other funds or borrows. In September 2026 the council agreed to borrow an additional $267.3 million for these lawsuits, according to news reports, before the 2027 proposal asked for more.
The proposal
The mayor's plan borrows about $481 million, usually rounded to $480 million, in two steps: about $350 million in 2027 and the rest, about $131 million, in 2028. The bonds would be repaid over five to seven years. The city's Department of Finance estimated an interest rate of about 6.9 percent on the first $350 million, and public reports on the interest cost range from more than $139 million to about $190 million, depending on the repayment schedule assumed. The principal and interest would be repaid from the city's budget in later years.
The budget effect is large because of how the budget gap is counted. The mayor called settlement costs the biggest single driver of the corporate fund shortfall of $882.4 million for 2027. Spreading the cost of settlements over years takes that cost out of the 2027 gap. Officials and aldermen disagree about how much, and whether the borrowing should count as closing the gap at all; the arithmetic is walked through in reading a budget gap: the $882 million corporate fund shortfall.
The case for borrowing
The administration's argument has several parts.
- The obligation is real and fixed. The city has agreed to settlements or faces cases that it expects to lose or settle. The amounts are court-supervised or negotiated, and the city cannot decline to pay.
- A lump of cost in one year would force deep cuts. Paying hundreds of millions of dollars out of one year's corporate fund would mean cutting services or raising taxes by that amount at once. Bond payments spread the effect.
- Settling now costs less than litigating. Officials estimated that settling the cases could save the city $300 million to $400 million compared with continuing to litigate them, since interest and legal fees accumulate while a case is pending and verdicts can exceed settlement offers.
- Other governments borrow for judgments. Municipal finance rules allow bonds for settlement and judgment costs, and the city has used them before.
The case against
Critics, including several aldermen who spoke during budget hearings, raise different objections.
- It borrows to pay for operations. Bonds are normally used for long-lived assets such as roads, buildings and water mains. Using debt for settlements pays for something with no lasting asset behind it, and critics argue that it hides recurring costs.
- Interest makes it more expensive. Interest of more than $139 million on $350 million, by the city's own estimate, is a cost on top of the settlements.
- It does not address the cause. The lawsuits come from past misconduct, and settlements, the argument goes, will continue until the department changes its practices. Borrowing helps the budget balance and does nothing about the conduct.
- It adds to a heavy debt burden. Chicago already carries large debts and pension obligations, and some aldermen and civic groups argue that adding more weakens the city's credit.
- The precedent. A few members called borrowing for settlements unprecedented in Chicago's practice and worried about the signal it sends.
Nobody on either side disputes that the settlements are large or that they are owed. The fight is over how to pay and what the borrowing signals.
What a borrowed dollar costs
Bond math gets lost in the totals, so here is a simple illustration, labeled as one. Say the city borrowed $350 million at 6.923 percent, the rate its Department of Finance estimated, and repaid it in seven equal annual payments. Each payment would be about $64.8 million. Over seven years the city would pay about $453 million, which is the $350 million it borrowed plus about $103 million in interest. A schedule that repays principal more slowly, or at a higher rate, produces a larger interest bill; the interest estimates published in October 2026 are higher than this illustration, which shows how much the schedule matters. The exact figure is not the point. A borrowed dollar costs more than a dollar, and the cost arrives over many budgets, including those of mayors and councils not yet elected.
The other side of the arithmetic is the year-one effect. Interest on $350 million at 6.923 percent is about $24 million in the first year, far below the hundreds of millions of dollars the settlements themselves cost. That is why borrowing makes the 2027 gap look smaller, and why critics describe it as shifting cost rather than removing it.
Why the cases come in bunches
Many of the largest settlements come from groups of lawsuits tied to a single officer or unit. When a court vacates one conviction because of fabricated evidence, other people convicted on the same officer's work may seek to overturn theirs, and the same pattern follows in civil suits. A global settlement, like the $260.8 million agreement approved in October 2026, resolves a group of cases at once. Earlier council votes approved tens of millions of dollars in other groups of cases, including a $90 million payout in a case involving a former sergeant accused of framing people for drug crimes. For a budget, this has two effects. Costs are lumpy, so a single year can be far above the average. And a number of cases can be predicted years ahead, because the underlying events are in the public record, which is the administration's argument for treating them as known obligations rather than surprises.
Oversight and the money
The money question is tied to a separate effort to change the department's practices. Oversight of the police in Chicago is shared among several bodies: the Civilian Office of Police Accountability investigates complaints of misconduct, the Chicago Police Board decides discipline cases, and the Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability, created by a July 2021 ordinance, gives residents a role in policy. How these bodies work and where they overlap is the subject of Police oversight in Chicago: COPA, the Police Board and the CCPSA, and the broader question of who watches whom at City Hall is in Who polices City Hall: the Board of Ethics and the Inspector General. The department itself is described in Chicago Police Department.
Watching it go through the council
The path from here is the same as for any line of the budget. The proposal is reviewed in committee hearings, the council can amend it, and the final budget ordinance is adopted by a vote of the 50 aldermen. The borrowing itself would need separate authorization, since bonds are issued under their own ordinance. The council's special meetings were noticed for November 18, 2026, and regular meetings for December 8 and 9. The agenda posted by the City Clerk for each date lists what is actually on the table, and the mayor's budget address: a reader's guide explains how to read the proposal as a whole. For what a vote looks like from the gallery, see Chicago City Council.
Three questions to carry into the debate
- How much of the borrowing is for cases that have already settled, and how much is for cases the city expects to settle? The first is a known amount. The second depends on judgments about future litigation.
- What happens to the budget line for settlements? If the city keeps budgeting about $82 million a year and the actual cost stays higher, the shortfall returns.
- What does the repayment schedule look like in 2030? Debt service is a fixed cost that competes with everything else the corporate fund pays for.
Every municipal budget teaches the same lesson. A cost does not go away when it moves from the operating budget to the bond market. It changes shape: smaller this year, larger and longer later, with interest. Whether that trade is wise depends on how the city's other obligations look, on what the cases ahead will cost, and on whether the practices behind the lawsuits change. The council's vote on the proposal will answer the first of those, and the department's record in the years after will answer the others.