Blog

Police oversight in Chicago: COPA, the Police Board and the CCPSA

Three civilian bodies oversee Chicago police: COPA investigates complaints, the Police Board decides discipline and the CCPSA sets policy goals.

Ask three Chicagoans who watches the police and you may get three different answers, and all of them will be partly right. The Chicago Police Department has a superintendent and a chain of command, and it also has three separate civilian bodies that sit outside that chain: the Civilian Office of Police Accountability, the Chicago Police Board, and the Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability. Each does a different job. One takes in complaints and investigates, one decides discipline in serious cases, and one sets priorities and has a hand in who fills the top jobs. The result is among the more elaborate oversight structures of any large American city, and it is worth sorting out because the three are so easy to mix up.

The three at a glance

Body Main job Created Contact (as listed by the city)
Civilian Office of Police Accountability (COPA) Investigates complaints of police misconduct and certain incidents Replaced an earlier agency in 2017 1615 W. Chicago Ave., 4th Floor; 312.746.3609
Chicago Police Board Decides discipline in the most serious cases Long-standing city board 2 N. LaSalle St., Suite M800; 312.742.4194
Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability (CCPSA) Sets goals and policy priorities, has a role in selecting leaders July 2021 ordinance Through the city's directory of departments

The police department itself, headquartered at 3510 S. Michigan Avenue, has its own internal affairs process and is described at Chicago Police Department.

COPA: the investigator

COPA is the first stop for most complaints. It was created to replace the Independent Police Review Authority and began work in 2017. According to the city, COPA is based at 1615 W. Chicago Avenue and can be reached at 312.746.3609.

What COPA handles falls into two groups. The first is complaints from the public about certain kinds of conduct. These include allegations of excessive force, domestic violence by an officer, coercion, and verbal abuse that is bias-based. The second is incidents COPA looks into on its own whether or not anyone files a complaint, such as police shootings and deaths in custody. Complaints outside these categories, for example about rudeness or neglect of duty, are generally handled by the police department's own internal process.

COPA investigators gather evidence, interview witnesses and officers, and review video and records. At the end of an investigation COPA issues findings: whether the allegation was sustained, not sustained, unfounded or the officer was exonerated. If it finds misconduct, it recommends discipline, and the case goes to the department. If the recommended discipline is serious enough, the process can lead to the Police Board. COPA is a city office led by a chief administrator, and it is independent of the police department.

Anyone can file a complaint, including people who were not the subject of the encounter. The city's COPA page lists the ways to file.

The Police Board: the decider

The Chicago Police Board is a civilian board whose members are appointed by the mayor. Its address is 2 N. LaSalle Street, Suite M800, and the phone is 312.742.4194. Its best-known job is hearing cases in which the superintendent seeks to fire an officer or to impose a long suspension. The board holds a hearing, with evidence and witnesses, much like a trial, and then decides whether the charges are proven and what discipline fits. Its decisions are public.

The Police Board has other responsibilities that the city lists, including a role in the process of finding a superintendent and in reviewing certain matters that come before it. For a resident the useful thing to remember is that the board is where serious discipline cases are decided, and that it sits between the investigation and the final outcome.

The CCPSA: the policy body

The Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability was created by a Chicago ordinance in July 2021. It is a newer and different kind of body, and its design reflects years of debate over how to give residents a say in policing.

Here is how it is built:

  • District councils. Each of the city's 22 police districts has a council of three members elected by the voters in that district. The councils are the community-facing arm of the system, meant to give residents of each district a forum and a voice.
  • The commission. The district councils together nominate candidates for the seven-member commission, and the mayor selects seven from the nominees.
  • Powers. The commission sets goals and priorities for the police department, COPA and the Police Board and evaluates their progress. It plays a central role in choosing and, in some cases, removing the superintendent, members of the Police Board and COPA's chief administrator. It can also issue a vote of no confidence in the superintendent, the COPA chief or a Police Board member, which forces a hearing in the City Council's public safety committee.

The commission does not run the police department. It does not investigate individual complaints and it does not decide individual discipline cases. Its work is policy, leadership and accountability in general. Supporters of the structure say it gives communities, not only the mayor, a role in shaping policing. Critics have questioned whether elected district councils can carry out their duties effectively and whether the overlapping powers breed confusion about who is in charge. Both views show up in the debate that has followed the commission since it was set up.

Which one do I use?

A short guide:

  1. You want to report an officer's conduct (force, domestic violence, coercion, bias-based abuse) or an incident: file with COPA.
  2. You want to understand how a serious discipline case is decided, or watch one: the Police Board posts its hearing schedule and decisions.
  3. You want to weigh in on policing priorities in your district, attend your police district council's meetings, or follow the commission.
  4. You have a complaint that is about a different kind of conduct, or about service: the police department and 311 are the starting points. Using 311 and the CHI311 app explains 311.
  5. Someone is in danger: call 911.

How the three connect: a walk-through

Take a made-up example. Say a resident reports that an officer used force during a stop. The report goes to COPA, which opens an investigation. COPA collects video, interviews witnesses and reviews records, then issues findings. If COPA finds that the officer violated policy, it recommends discipline to the superintendent. If the superintendent agrees that the officer should be fired, or suspended for a long period, the case goes to the Police Board, which holds a hearing and decides. Meanwhile the commission, which does not touch this case, may be setting a policy goal on use of force for the whole department and checking progress against it, and the district council in the area may be hearing from neighbors about the same subject.

That sequence shows the division of labor. COPA investigates, the board decides, the commission sets direction. The police department carries out the discipline and the policies.

How the structure came together

The three bodies arrived at different moments. The Police Board is the oldest, a long-standing city board with the power to decide serious discipline cases. COPA is more recent: it replaced the Independent Police Review Authority and began operating in 2017, a change that came after public pressure over how police misconduct was investigated. The Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability came last, through the July 2021 ordinance. The elected district councils the ordinance created held their first elections in 2023.

Each addition answered a gap people saw in what came before. COPA was meant to be a more independent investigator. The commission was meant to give communities a say in policy and in who leads the oversight bodies, a role that neither COPA nor the Police Board had. That layering is why the system can look crowded, and why it helps to ask what a particular body does that the others do not.

Questions people ask

Does filing a complaint cost anything? No. Filing with COPA is free, and the city's page lists the ways to do it.

Can I attend Police Board hearings? The board's hearings are public, and its schedule and decisions are posted on its page on chicago.gov.

Does the commission handle individual complaints? No. It works on policy, goals and leadership selection. Individual complaints go to COPA, or to the police department for matters outside COPA's categories.

Who appoints the superintendent? The commission plays a central role in the selection process, and the mayor and council have their own roles. The exact steps are set by the ordinance and the Municipal Code, and the city's pages describe them.

Is there a body for my police district? Yes. Each of the 22 police districts has an elected district council, and its meetings are open to residents. The commission's pages list how to find yours.

Other watchdogs

Two more bodies touch the police without being part of the three.

  • The Office of Inspector General is independent and receives reports of misconduct, waste and abuse by city officials, employees and contractors. It also audits city programs, including those of the police department. Who polices City Hall: the Board of Ethics and the Inspector General describes its role beside the Board of Ethics.
  • The City Council holds hearings in its public safety committee, passes the ordinances that set the structure, and votes on the police budget each year. The 2027 budget proposal includes a plan to borrow money to pay for settlements of police misconduct cases, which is a separate matter from discipline. paying for police misconduct settlements: the borrowing proposal explains it.

Reading the system

Two observations help make sense of it. First, the three bodies were created at different times for different reasons, which is why their jobs overlap at the edges. Second, the rules are set by city ordinance, and ordinances can be amended. The council has changed these arrangements before and can again, so the current details are worth checking on the official pages.

For the police department itself, the contact numbers and the structure of districts, see Chicago Police Department. The city's directory of departments, at chicago.gov, lists each oversight body with its address and phone. For safety information for residents, see Staying safe in Chicago: general habits that help.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic