Blog
The Burnham Plan of 1909
Daniel Burnham and Edward Bennett's Plan of Chicago: what it proposed for the lakefront, rails and streets, what got built, and what it left in today's parks.
"Make no little plans." Every Chicago planner, alderman and chamber-of-commerce speechwriter has leaned on that line, and it is pinned to Daniel Burnham. The attribution came after his death, and nobody can say for certain he said it in those words. The document that carried his name, the Plan of Chicago of 1909, was anything but little. It was a bound book of maps, bird's-eye paintings and argument, published by the Commercial Club of Chicago, and it proposed rebuilding the relationship between a city of two million people and its lake, its railroads, its streets and its countryside.
Most of it was never built. But a surprising amount of what makes Chicago look the way it does, the lakefront above all, traces back to the ideas in that book.
Who wrote it, and why
Burnham was the architect and planner who had directed the construction of the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition (see The World's Columbian Exposition of 1893), which showed that a big site could be laid out as one orderly composition. The plan came out of the Merchants Club, whose project began in 1906, and was carried on by the Commercial Club, a group of business leaders. Burnham and Edward H. Bennett wrote it, and the artist Jules Guérin painted its striking bird's-eye views. The plan was presented to the city in July 1909 and published that year.
The motive was part civic pride and part business sense. Chicago's leaders believed a better-organized city would be a more productive and attractive one. Congested streets, a tangle of competing railroad stations and a lakefront crowded with industry and private property were costs the city did not have to bear.
What it proposed
The plan covered the region, not just the city. Its main recommendations, in plain terms, were:
- Keep the lakefront public. The central idea was that the shore of Lake Michigan should belong to everyone, as a continuous chain of parks, beaches and harbors.
- A system of regional highways. The plan sketched radial and circumferential roads across a region about 75 miles across.
- Consolidate the rail terminals. Six passenger stations would be merged into a smaller number, with tracks and approaches reorganized.
- A larger outer park system. It supported the forest preserves and the extension of the city's parks and boulevards.
- Wider and straighter streets. It proposed wider arterial streets and diagonal avenues to ease traffic.
- A civic center and cultural center. A new complex for government and, in Grant Park, for cultural institutions.
What was built, and what was not
| Proposal | Outcome |
|---|---|
| A public lakefront | Largely achieved: most of the shoreline is public parkland today |
| Regional highways | Built later, but the builders of the 1910s and 1920s did not closely follow the plan's routes |
| Consolidated rail terminals | Not carried out; only a new Union Station, finished in 1925, was built |
| South Branch of the river | Rechanneled in 1929 to ease rail approaches |
| Outer parks | Supported the forest preserves and park expansion |
| Wider streets | Michigan Avenue, Roosevelt Road, Wacker Drive and Ida B. Wells Drive were improved; the growth of the automobile led planners away from many of the street proposals |
| Civic center | Never seriously pursued |
| Cultural center in Grant Park | Blocked by a state supreme court ruling against new buildings there |
Burnham died in 1912. Bennett carried on as an adviser to public agencies on projects, and the Chicago Plan Commission, created to promote the plan, kept a public conversation going. Enthusiasm waned during the Great Depression, though parts of the plan kept guiding public works. Critics have pointed out that the plan was fixed on physical improvements and said little about housing, wages and the lives of the people who lived in the neighborhoods it redrew.
The lakefront: the plan's best-known legacy
Treating the lakefront as shared open space is the plan's most visible result. Today most of Chicago's shoreline is parkland, and the Chicago Park District, which since 1934 has managed the city's parks (see how 22 park districts became one in 1934), counts about 26 miles of it. The Lakefront Trail, the beaches and the harbors that draw millions of visits a year are the descendants of the plan's central idea. the lakefront as a public good: how the shoreline stayed open and The Park District in numbers describe how that system works today.
Grant Park, the big park on the edge of the Loop, is the front lawn the plan imagined. The way it has been used, as the site of festivals, concerts, museums and the Art Institute, is covered in Grant Park: the city's front yard. The proposal for a cultural center within it was stopped by a state supreme court ruling that held the park should stay open, but the cultural institutions that gathered at its edge, including the museums on the Museum Campus (see The Museum Campus: Field Museum, Shedd Aquarium and Adler Planetarium), reflect the same impulse.
Rails and highways
The railroad part of the plan went furthest in the opposite direction from what it proposed. Instead of consolidating the terminals, Chicago kept its several downtown stations. The new Union Station, finished in 1925 and described in Union Station and Amtrak's Midwest hub, was the one major piece built. In 1929 the South Branch of the river was rechanneled to ease the approach for rail lines. The plan's proposals for regional highways were not followed closely, though the idea of a system of radial and ring routes came back when the expressways were built after World War II (see how the expressways were built).
The "Burnham" legacy in the street grid
Several streets the plan targeted were widened or improved: Michigan Avenue, Roosevelt Road, Wacker Drive and what is now Ida B. Wells Drive. Anyone who drives them today is using the legacy of the plan, whether or not they know it. The growth of the automobile changed the picture, and planners later departed from many of the specific street proposals. What survived was the principle that the city should be planned as a whole, not lot by lot.
A walk through the plan's legacy
The plan is easiest to understand on foot. A route that touches most of what it affected runs like this:
- Start on the lakefront in Grant Park. The open lawn between Michigan Avenue and the lake is the plan's idea of a public front yard, kept open by the courts.
- Walk west on Roosevelt Road to see one of the streets the plan targeted for widening and improvement.
- Follow Wacker Drive along the river. It is one of the improved streets, and it follows the bend of the main river through the Loop.
- Finish at Union Station, finished in 1925, the single terminal the plan produced from its proposal to consolidate the downtown rail stations.
Then look back at the lakefront. The plan's own argument was that a city could be both efficient and beautiful, and that public open space was an investment. Agree or not, the lakefront is the clearest case anyone in Chicago can point to.
Why a plan, and why then
By 1909 Chicago had been remade twice in a generation: by the rebuilding after the fire of 1871 and by the 1893 fair. It had also grown faster than its infrastructure. Passenger rail was divided among stations run by competing companies, each with its own approaches, so travelers changing trains had to cross the congested downtown from one station to the next. Streets built for horses were jammed with growing traffic. The business leaders who commissioned the plan argued that investing in order would pay off, and the argument had weight in a city that depended on its role as a rail hub.
The plan's authors also believed in the value of parks and open space for the health and morale of workers in a crowded industrial city, a belief shared by the settlement and reform movements of the period (see Hull House and the settlement movement). The idea that the lake should be a common good fit that outlook.
Four ideas that outlasted the plan
- Treat the city as a whole. Streets, rail, parks and public buildings were presented as parts of one system.
- Plan for the region. The plan looked well beyond the city limits, to a region about 75 miles across.
- Protect public access to the water. The lakefront was to be a chain of parks, not private frontage.
- Persuade the public. The plan was a book written for citizens, with pictures meant to be shown and discussed. The Chicago Plan Commission and the Commercial Club promoted it in schools and meetings, which is how a private document became a public cause.
What the critics said
Critics, then and since, have made several points. The plan was a plan for the downtown and the lakefront more than for the neighborhoods where most Chicagoans lived. It said little about housing or wages. Its civic center and its grand axes owed more to European models than to local needs. And in its focus on physical improvement it assumed that a better-looking city would be a better one. Supporters answer that no plan can do everything, and that the lakefront parks and the idea of public planning are lasting gifts.
How planning works in the city now
Planning in the city today is led by the Department of Planning and Development, covered in Chicago Department of Planning and Development, which handles zoning, historic preservation, development incentives and neighborhood plans. The park system sits with the Chicago Park District (Chicago Park District). The lakefront is further protected by city ordinance, and large proposals along it are subject to public debate, which is part of the plan's legacy: an expectation that decisions about the shore belong to the public.
Questions people ask
Did Burnham really say "Make no little plans"? The line is attributed to him after his death. Treat it as a motto associated with the plan, not as a verified quotation.
Did the city follow the plan? Partly. The lakefront parks are the strongest example. Other major elements, such as the consolidation of rail stations and the civic center, were not carried out.
Was it only about Chicago? No. It addressed a region about 75 miles across.
What happened to the plan's authors? Burnham died in 1912. Bennett continued advising public agencies on projects.
Where can I see it? Walk the lakefront from the Loop through Grant Park and along the shore, or visit the Museum Campus; see South Loop and The Loop for the neighborhoods at the edge of the park.