Blog
The lakefront as a public good: how the shoreline stayed open
From an 1839 plat to the 1909 Plan of Chicago and the 1934 Park District, how most of Chicago's Lake Michigan shoreline ended up as public parkland.
Stand on the Lakefront Trail anywhere between Edgewater and the South Shore and look east. Water, a strip of grass or sand, a path. Look west and it is a park, a boulevard or a drive, and only then the buildings. Chicago is one of the few big American cities where the shoreline of a great lake is mostly open to the public, and it is open on purpose. It took a notation on a map, a mail-order millionaire's lawsuits, a book of plans and a state law to make it so. Nobody handed it over.
A map that said "public ground"
It starts with a surveyor's drawing. In 1839, two years after the city's charter, the townsite plan marked the strip east of Michigan Avenue as public ground, to remain vacant of buildings. In 1844 the city formally designated the land as a park, called Lake Park. The phrase on the map, in the form the courts later quoted, said the land was to remain "forever open, clear and free" of buildings and obstructions.
Reality was messier. In 1852 the Illinois Central Railroad was allowed to lay track on a causeway built out in the lake, which gave the railroad a corridor along the shore that is still partly in use. The stagnant lagoon between the causeway and the shore was largely filled after the Great Chicago Fire of 1871 with the fire's rubble. The old restrictions on the strip were often ignored, and civic buildings kept being proposed for ground the map said should stay empty.
Montgomery Ward goes to court
Enter Aaron Montgomery Ward, who built a mail-order business and objected to buildings going up on the strip. Unlike most objectors he had the money to sue and the stubbornness to keep suing. Over the 1890s and the first decade of the 1900s he brought four separate cases to keep the strip clear. The Illinois Supreme Court sided with him each time, on a theory that land dedicated to the public by the original plat could not later be handed over to buildings.
The court did make exceptions. The Art Institute of Chicago, built in 1892-93, was allowed because the interested property owners consented. Otherwise the open lakefront west of the railroad, from Randolph Street south, stayed open. Historians of the Illinois courts point to that run of cases as the legal anchor of the public lakefront, and for more than a century the doctrine kept significant buildings out of Grant Park. The park was renamed Grant Park in 1901. Ward's lawsuits made the next step possible, a plan for the whole shoreline.
The 1909 plan
Daniel Burnham and Edward Bennett's Plan of Chicago was commissioned by the Commercial Club of Chicago, a group of business leaders. It was published in 1909 and presented to the city that July. It argued for many things: boulevards, railroad consolidation, a civic center. The lakefront was its clearest theme. "The Lakefront by right belongs to the people," Burnham wrote, and the plan proposed to extend the shoreline's parks with landfill and to keep the whole edge for public use rather than letting factories, rail yards and private frontage take it.
Only parts of the plan were built, and enthusiasm faded in the Great Depression. The lakefront was the part that mostly was. In the 1910s and 1920s, landfill made the ground for the Field Museum, the Shedd Aquarium and the Adler Planetarium, the Museum Campus that sits at the southern end of Grant Park today, and for the long strip of parkland later called Burnham Park, which connects Grant Park to Jackson Park on the South Side. Plan or no plan, the principle of the public lakefront was set. The plan did not win every argument: its proposed cultural center for Grant Park ran into the Supreme Court's building ban and was dropped. Where the legal doctrine and the planning idea collided, the law won.
One park district
By the 1930s the lakefront parks belonged to a patchwork of authorities. Lincoln Park had been created in 1860 and the three big districts, Lincoln, West and South, were established in 1869. Each ran its own system. The Park Consolidation Act, passed by the Illinois legislature, merged 22 separate districts into the Chicago Park District on May 1, 1934. For the shoreline, consolidation meant a single manager from north to south, a single budget, a single set of rules for beaches, harbors and paths. The district today reports 26 miles of lakefront under its care, along with more than 600 parks and more than 8,800 acres overall; see The Park District in numbers for those figures worked out. The founding of the district is covered in how 22 park districts became one in 1934, and the background on the Burnham era is in The Burnham Plan of 1909.
The trail
The path most people mean when they say "the lakefront" came last. In 1963 Mayor Richard J. Daley designated a route along the water as the city's first official bike path. Over the following decades more users arrived: runners, cyclists, skaters, dog walkers, commuters, and families headed to the beach, all sharing a trail that runs about 18 miles (some sources say 18.5) through Lincoln Park, Grant Park, Burnham Park and Jackson Park.
Crowding became the trail's central problem. The Navy Pier area was a particular choke point, where the trail ran onto the lower Lake Shore Drive sidewalk between Wacker Drive and Illinois Street. The Navy Pier Flyover, designed beginning in 2000 and under construction from 2014, took cyclists up and over that stretch and finished in May 2021. A separate Trail Separation Project in 2017-2018 widened lanes and gave walkers and riders their own paths in busy sections. The city's guide to riding the trail and to the Divvy bike share is in Biking in Chicago: the Lakefront Trail and Divvy, and a mile-by-mile tour is in The Lakefront Trail from end to end.
The park district has also announced repair work, starting south and moving north. Current closures and detours are on the district's site.
Why it stayed open
Ask how the shoreline stayed public and the honest answer comes in several parts, in sequence. First, a line on a map that gave later courts something to enforce. Second, a private citizen willing to litigate. Third, a regional plan that made the open shore a civic goal rather than an obstruction to remove. Fourth, a single park authority with the legal power to manage the whole edge. None would have been enough alone: the plat without Ward's lawsuits would have been ignored, and Ward's victories without the plan and the district would have left the shoreline protected but unmanaged.
It stayed open, too, because people used it. A beach on a hot day, a trail on a summer morning, a fireworks night at Navy Pier create a public that notices when something is proposed for the shore. A resident who wants to follow a proposal for lakefront land has a paper trail to work with: the City Council's agendas and journals on the Clerk's site are public, and the Clerk's legislation search is described in How a Chicago ordinance goes from introduction to a council vote. The tradition Ward started, a private citizen asking a court to enforce a public promise, is still how many disputes over the shore begin. Proposals for stadiums, museums and housing on or near the lakefront keep coming up, and the debate always goes back to the questions Ward, Burnham and the courts argued.
Four parks, four jobs
The public shoreline is not one park but a chain, and each link has its own history.
- Lincoln Park is the oldest and the largest, 1,208 acres stretching about seven miles from Grand Avenue to near Ardmore. It began in 1860 as Chicago's first large park and holds the zoo, the nature museum and several beaches and harbors. Lincoln Park: the park and the neighborhood that share a name covers it from the neighborhood side.
- Grant Park is the front yard of the Loop, the strip Ward fought for. Millennium Park, which opened on July 16, 2004, takes up 24.5 acres of its northwestern corner. Grant Park's eastern half is mostly the landfill of the early twentieth century. Grant Park: the city's front yard tells that story.
- Burnham Park runs south from the Museum Campus and connects Grant Park to Jackson Park. It is the Plan of Chicago's idea in its purest form: a long strip of made land beside the water, kept as parkland.
- Jackson Park is the south end. The South Park Commission hired Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux in 1869 to lay it out, and in 1893 it became the site of the World's Columbian Exposition. Jackson Park: the fair, the lagoons and the future follows it from the fair to the present.
Between those four, the trail passes beaches, harbors and open lawns that belong to the same system. The Park District's single management is what lets a rider cross from one park into the next without noticing the boundary.
Walking the history
Most of this fits on one walk. Start at the Art Institute on Michigan Avenue, the building Ward consented to. Cross into Grant Park and look east across Columbus Drive toward the railroad tracks that follow the old Illinois Central causeway. Continue to the Museum Campus on the landfill Burnham's plan imagined. Then follow the Lakefront Trail north toward Lincoln Park or south toward Hyde Park. The Park District's 26 miles are continuous enough that you can walk or ride most of them without leaving parkland. For a place to start, see The Loop, Lincoln Park or Hyde Park, and for the agency itself, Chicago Park District.