Blog
The Chicago-style hot dog and the ketchup rule
What goes on a Chicago-style hot dog, the seven toppings and the poppy seed bun, why ketchup is left off, and where the dish comes from.
Walk up to a hot dog counter in this town and ask for a hot dog, and the person behind the glass will bark one word back at you: "Everything?" In most places that settles it. Everything means a steamed or simmered all-beef frank in a poppy seed bun, loaded with yellow mustard, chopped white onions, bright green sweet pickle relish, a dill pickle spear, slices of tomato, pickled sport peppers and a dash of celery salt. It does not mean ketchup. Ask for ketchup and you will get a look that has been known to stop traffic on Western Avenue. What follows is what the dish is, how it gets built and where the rule against the red stuff comes from.
The dog, the bun and the toppings
A Chicago-style hot dog starts with an all-beef frankfurter, traditionally in a natural casing, which gives the skin a snap when you bite it. The usual cooking method is to steam or simmer it, though some vendors char-grill it. The bun is a poppy seed bun, soft and slightly sweet, steamed so it stays warm and tender.
Then comes the garden. The standard toppings are:
- Yellow mustard. Plain yellow mustard, not a brown or specialty kind.
- Chopped white onions.
- Sweet pickle relish, famously a vivid, almost neon green.
- A dill pickle spear, laid along the dog.
- Tomato slices or wedges, tucked in beside the pickle.
- Pickled sport peppers, small, hot and tangy.
- Celery salt, shaken on at the end.
The finished dog is said to have been "dragged through the garden," and the toppings do read like a salad: onion, tomato, pickle, pepper and herbs on a bun. Each does a different job. The mustard is sharp, the relish is sweet, the onion is raw and pungent, the pickle is sour, the tomato adds juice and the sport peppers add heat. The celery salt ties the rest together with a savory, slightly bitter finish. The whole thing is built to go down in a handful of bites, and the point of the combination is that no single flavor gets to bully the beef.
The ketchup rule
Ketchup is widely rejected on a Chicago-style hot dog. Many vendors refuse to put it on a dog that is "Chicago style," some keep the bottle out of sight, and a recipe that includes ketchup is not the traditional one. It is one of the best-known food customs in the city, and it is often delivered as a joke, though plenty of people are not joking.
Several explanations make the rounds.
- The history of the meat. One story ties the rule to ketchup's use in earlier eras to mask the taste of poor meat, a worry sharpened by Upton Sinclair's 1906 novel The Jungle, which exposed conditions in Chicago's meatpacking industry. A hot dog made from good beef, the argument goes, needs no cover.
- Balance. Defenders say the toppings already supply sweetness through the relish and sourness through the pickle and mustard, and that ketchup adds a competing sweetness that muddles the balance.
- Tradition. For a lot of people the answer is simpler: that is how it is done, and a custom does not owe anybody an explanation.
The rule is mostly a norm, not a law, and it is enforced with humor. Children are usually forgiven. But at a stand that calls its product Chicago-style, the expectation is that the toppings are the seven above and that ketchup is not one of them.
Where the dish comes from
The hot dog's roots here go back to the nineteenth century and to the immigrant neighborhoods. Vienna-style frankfurters came to the city with European immigrants, and the story most often told is that two immigrant sausage makers sold kosher all-beef frankfurters at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition and founded a company the following year. The fair itself is described in The World's Columbian Exposition of 1893.
The modern pile of toppings is usually traced to the Great Depression and to the open-air market on Maxwell Street on the Near West Side. Vendors there sold a cheap, filling meal for a nickel. One well-known version, sold at the time, was loaded with lettuce, tomato, onions, peppers, mustard and relish, and served with fries. It was nicknamed the Depression Dog, and the idea of putting a full plate of vegetables on a hot dog became part of the city's food. The market's story, and the Polish sausage sandwich that came out of it, are told in The Maxwell Street Polish and the old market.
The dish also carries the city's industrial past. Chicago was the center of the American meatpacking industry after the Union Stock Yards opened on December 25, 1865, and a food built on affordable beef fits that history. The stockyards and the American meatpacking story goes into the connection in more depth, and the neighborhood that grew up around the yards is described in Back of the Yards after the stockyards.
How to order
The language of the counter is short, because the line behind you is not.
- "Everything" or "with everything" means all seven toppings.
- "Dragged through the garden" means the same, in more colorful language.
- Hold an item by saying so directly: "no onions" or "no peppers."
- "Char dog" or "charred" asks for a grilled frank where the stand offers one.
- "Depression dog" at stands that carry it refers to the version with fries on the bun.
If you want a traditional Chicago dog, say "Chicago" or "everything" and leave the ketchup alone. If you want something else, a good stand will make it, and most vendors take a plain request without comment.
Eating one
The Chicago dog is meant to be eaten standing up, with a napkin and maybe a side of fries. It is a food of ballparks, street corners, drive-ins and neighborhood stands, and it turns up at the Cubs' Wrigley Field, which opened on April 23, 1914, and at the White Sox's ballpark, next to the stadium food of any American city. It is also an everyday meal: cheap, fast and made to order. A stand turns out a dog in minutes, and a typical order is the dog, fries and a soda.
The seasons matter. Hot dog stands do their best business in the warm months, when walkers fill the sidewalks and the ballparks are open, but they run all year, and a steaming dog on a bitter January day is its own pleasure. The city's calendar of eating is in A year of Chicago eating, by season.
Making one at home
The recipe is simple, and the work is in the assembly.
- Steam or simmer all-beef franks until heated through.
- Warm poppy seed buns by steaming them briefly so they are soft.
- Put the frank in the bun, then add toppings in a sensible order: mustard, relish, chopped onions, tomato slices, a pickle spear and sport peppers.
- Finish with a sprinkle of celery salt.
Sport peppers and poppy seed buns are specialty items that can be harder to find outside the Midwest, and many home cooks order them. The sweet relish traditionally used is the bright green kind. Keep the ketchup in the refrigerator, where it belongs.
Questions people ask
Is it the only hot dog in Chicago? No. Stands also sell plain dogs, chili dogs, cheese dogs and corn dogs, and the Chicago-style dog is a particular build, not the city's only hot dog. What sets it apart is the full set of toppings and the all-beef frank.
Is the poppy seed bun required? For the traditional version, yes. The seeds give the bun its look and a faint nutty flavor, and the bun is one of the parts that separates a Chicago dog from other regional styles.
Why a pickle spear and tomato wedges? They add crunch, acid and juice. The spear and the tomato sit alongside the frank, so each bite gets a bit of everything.
Why celery salt? It is the last seasoning, and it ties together the sweet, sour and hot flavors of the toppings with a savory note. You will notice when it is missing.
Is a Maxwell Street Polish the same thing? No. That sandwich is a grilled Polish sausage with onions and mustard, with its own history in the same market district; it is covered in The Maxwell Street Polish and the old market.
Hot dog stands and the city
A hot dog stand is a small business, and in Chicago it is a licensed one. The Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection handles business licensing, and food vendors are subject to health inspection. The rules for mobile food vendors, which cover many hot dog carts and trucks, are a subject of their own in What a food truck needs to operate in Chicago. The department is profiled at Chicago Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection.
Why the dish endures
The Chicago-style hot dog lasts because it is a complete, cheap meal that tastes like the city: immigrant food, packinghouse beef and the market streets of the Depression years, with a set of rules that everyone knows and enjoys breaking. The ketchup debate is its public face, but the dish stands up without it: a snapping frank, a soft bun and seven toppings that each do their part. A visitor who orders one "with everything" is joining a tradition older than most of the buildings downtown, and doing it for a few dollars and a paper boat of fries. For other local classics, see italian beef: dipped, hot and sweet and Deep dish and tavern cut: Chicago's two pizza traditions.