Blog
Deep dish and tavern cut: Chicago's two pizza traditions
Two Chicago pizzas compared as traditions: how a deep-dish pie is built upside down, how a thin tavern-cut pie differs and how each is eaten at home and out.
Ask a visitor to name a Chicago food and you get the same answer every time: deep-dish pizza, a pie baked in a tall pan with the sauce on top. Ask somebody who has lived here for years what they ordered the last time they went out for pizza with friends, and you hear something else entirely: a thin, crisp, square-cut pie that came to the table on a cutting board. Chicago has two pizza traditions, and each has its own build, its own bake and its own moments. What follows compares both as traditions, not as a ranking of the places that make them.
The two pies at a glance
| Deep dish | Tavern style | |
|---|---|---|
| Crust | Tall, with a thick edge that forms a wall around the filling | Thin and crisp, with little rise |
| Build | Crust, then cheese, then toppings, then tomato sauce on top | Sauce, cheese and toppings on a thin base, like most pizza |
| Bake | Long; the pie is in the oven for a good while | Short and hot |
| Cut | Wedges, often only a few slices per pie | Small squares |
| Eaten with | A knife and fork, in many cases | Hands, a square at a time |
| Occasion | A sit-down meal; it takes time | A shared plate with drinks |
The details below fill in each column.
How a deep-dish pizza is built
Deep dish is built upside down compared with other pizza. A pan, round and straight-sided, is oiled, and the dough is pressed into it so that it climbs the sides, forming a high edge. The cheese goes in first, directly on the dough. Toppings, such as sausage, vegetables and pepperoni, go on top of the cheese. Last comes the tomato sauce, usually crushed tomatoes with seasoning, ladled over everything. Then the pie goes into the oven.
The order has a logic. A pie this deep needs a long time to bake, long enough that cheese on top would scorch before the crust cooked. Putting the sauce on top shields the cheese and toppings, and putting the cheese against the dough keeps the crust from soaking up tomato juice. What comes out is a pie with a crisp, almost biscuit-like crust, a thick layer of melted cheese and a bright tomato layer that is the first thing you see and taste. Written histories credit its invention to a downtown pizzeria in 1943, though in a food culture this attached to a local dish, claims of precedence are common and rarely settled.
A related style, the stuffed pizza, is deeper still, with more cheese and a second layer of dough covering the toppings before the sauce goes on. It is a cousin to deep dish, not the same thing, and some Chicagoans keep the two names distinct.
What it means at the table
Deep dish takes a long time to bake, so many restaurants take the order and start the pie right away, and a visitor may wait a good while for it. It is common to order an appetizer or a drink and plan the meal around the wait. Deep dish is also filling: a few slices are a meal. The pie is typically cut in wedges and eaten with a knife and fork, because the tall slice is too heavy to fold or hold flat.
How a tavern-style pizza is built
Tavern style is the thin-crust pizza that is popular in Chicago, and it is the one many residents eat most often. The dough is rolled thin and baked until crisp, the sauce and cheese go on in the usual order, and the pie is cut into small squares instead of triangular wedges. The cut is called a tavern cut or a party cut, and it is the visual signature of the style. A thin cracker-like crust holds a square without bending, which makes it easy to pick up one piece at a time and keep talking.
The name tells you where the style belongs: the neighborhood tavern, where pizza came out of the kitchen on a board for a table of friends or a bar of regulars. The squares are meant for sharing and for eating over a long conversation, and a pie lasts as long as the table does.
How locals use each one
A bit of local wisdom, repeated often enough to count as custom: deep dish is for occasions, tavern style is for every day. A family with out-of-town guests will often take them for deep dish, because it is what visitors expect to try and it makes a long, sit-down dinner. A group of friends going out after work, or a family ordering in on a weeknight, is more likely to order thin. Many households have a favorite for each, and it is not unusual to hear Chicagoans say they like both.
At home the two behave differently. A thin pie, delivered or picked up, is quick, travels well and reheats fairly well. A deep-dish pie is heavy and slow, and many households treat it as a weekend meal or a dish to make from scratch. Home bakers who make deep dish use a deep, round pan and follow the same build as above: dough pressed up the sides, cheese, toppings, then sauce, and a long bake in a hot oven.
Why a city has two
It is easy to cast the two styles as rivals. Better to see them as answers to different questions. Deep dish answers the question of what a restaurant dinner built around pizza should be: an event, with a pie that needs waiting for and a heft that justifies the wait. Tavern style answers the question of what to put on a table of friends with drinks: something thin, quick and easy to share. Chicago grew up with a large working population, a strong Italian-American community and a dense network of neighborhood taverns and corner restaurants, and both pies fit that setting. The Italian-American side of the story is told in Italian-American Chicago: Little Italy and the Near West Side.
Food in Chicago also follows the seasons, and the calendar of what people eat when is laid out in A year of Chicago eating, by season. Pizza is a year-round food, but the heavy deep-dish dinner tends to feel right on a cold night, and the lighter pie suits a summer evening on a patio.
A short vocabulary
- Deep dish. The tall-pan pie with cheese on the bottom and sauce on top.
- Stuffed. A deeper relative with a second layer of dough over the toppings.
- Thin crust. The general term for a pizza with a thin base; in Chicago it often means tavern style.
- Tavern cut or party cut. Small squares instead of wedges.
- Pan. The deep, round, straight-sided baking pan that gives deep dish its shape.
- Chicago-style. A label restaurants use for either pie; ask which one is meant.
Choosing between them
If you want to understand what Chicagoans mean when they talk about pizza, try both. For a first visit with a few hours to spend, deep dish is the better introduction to the city's food: it is distinctive, it is the pie most closely tied to the city's reputation, and the wait is part of the experience. For a casual evening, a table with a thin pie and a few drinks is closer to how many residents actually eat. A visitor on a short trip who can have only one will usually be happiest with deep dish; a resident asked to pick for a Friday night will often pick thin.
Dietary needs matter here too. A deep-dish pie is dense and filling, and a smaller appetite can be satisfied by one slice, while a thin pie is lighter and easy to portion by the square. Restaurants that serve both can usually describe the toppings and sizes when you ask, and the staff will tell you how long a deep-dish order takes.
Ordering tips
- Ask how long the pie takes. Deep dish needs time. If you have a show to catch, tell the server when you order.
- Order the right size. A deep-dish pie is filling, so a small can feed two or three people.
- Know the cut. If you want the squares, ask for a tavern cut or a party cut; if you want wedges from a thin pie, say so.
- Share. Both styles are built for groups, and ordering one of each is a common way to try both.
- Check the check. Restaurants add the city's restaurant tax, 0.5 percent since January 1, 2020, to the bill, which is one of the items explained in the restaurant tax on your check.
A word on safety and trust
Restaurants in Chicago are licensed and inspected, and the results are public. The Chicago Department of Public Health conducts food safety inspections, and the Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection handles licensing. If you want to look into a place before you eat there, Reading a Chicago restaurant inspection report explains how to read an inspection report. The departments are profiled at Chicago Department of Public Health and Chicago Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection.
The other Chicago classics
Pizza is one of several foods that define the city's table. The all-beef hot dog and its famous list of toppings are described in The Chicago-style hot dog and the ketchup rule, and the dipped roast beef sandwich is described in italian beef: dipped, hot and sweet. Taken together, the dishes show a cuisine shaped by immigrant communities, working-class neighborhoods and the habit of eating well at modest prices, and the two pizzas are the best-known part of that tradition. A visitor who tries both, a deep-dish pie on a Saturday night and a tavern-cut pie at a neighborhood bar, will taste the range of what Chicago means by pizza.