Blog

The exchanges: CME Group, Cboe and the Board of Trade building

How a grain market founded in 1848 grew into the CME Group and Cboe, and why the Art Deco Board of Trade tower still anchors the foot of LaSalle Street.

On April 3, 1848, a handful of grain merchants started trading in a room above a flour store at 101 South Water Street. The Chicago Board of Trade was nothing grand then. It was a fix for a practical headache: the grain pouring into the new port from the prairie came in different qualities, at different times, from farmers who wanted a price and buyers who wanted a promise. Nearly two centuries on, the descendants of that room include a major derivatives exchange group and the first exchange to list standardized options, and the symbol of the whole enterprise is a thirty-one-foot statue of the Roman goddess of grain perched on top of a skyscraper in the Loop.

Why grain, and why Chicago

The founding year is no accident. The Illinois and Michigan Canal opened in 1848, linking Lake Michigan to the Illinois River, and the first railroad, the Galena and Chicago Union, was completed the same year. Chicago became the spot where the farms of the interior met the Great Lakes shipping routes. Grain that came in by rail and canal had to be stored, graded and sold, and merchants needed somewhere to do it under common rules. the canal, the railroads and the making of a hub tells that part of the story.

An exchange solves two problems. It standardizes the product, so a bushel of a given grade means the same thing to every buyer. And it lets people trade promises about the future, not just goods on hand. A farmer worried that prices will fall by harvest, and a baker worried that they will rise, can agree today on a price for delivery later. That agreement is a futures contract. Chicago's exchanges grew by standardizing such contracts and by building the clearing arrangements that make both sides trust one another.

The building at the foot of LaSalle Street

The Board of Trade has stood on the same site since 1885, when a building designed by William W. Boyington opened there. It was demolished in 1929 to make room for a taller one. The present Chicago Board of Trade Building opened on June 9, 1930. Holabird & Root designed it in the Art Deco style, and it rises 44 stories, about 604 feet, closing the view at the foot of LaSalle Street, the canyon of bank buildings that runs north from Jackson Boulevard. The address is 141 West Jackson Boulevard.

At the top stands the aluminum statue of Ceres. The sculptor, John H. Storrs, built her from about forty pieces. She is roughly thirty-one feet tall and weighs about 6,500 pounds, and she holds wheat in one hand and corn in the other. The building was designated a Chicago Landmark in 1977 and a National Historic Landmark in 1978.

Ownership has changed hands. In the early 2010s the CME Group sold the north and south towers to a real estate consortium and kept the smaller east building at 333 South LaSalle Street. The tower remains an office building with trading connections; see The architecture tour: from the Home Insurance Building to Willis Tower for how the Loop's towers fit together.

From the Mercantile Exchange to CME Group

The second great Chicago exchange, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, was founded in 1898. For most of the twentieth century it traded agricultural products. Its big leap came in the 1970s and 1980s, when the idea of a futures contract was stretched from commodities to financial instruments. In 1982 the Merc introduced the first successful stock index futures contract, which let investors hedge or bet on a whole market in a single trade.

The next steps were corporate. In 2000 the Mercantile Exchange demutualized, changing from a member-owned association into a joint stock company. In 2007 it merged with the holding company of the Chicago Board of Trade, in a transaction valued at about $8 billion, to form CME Group. In 2008 CME Group bought the New York Mercantile Exchange, which owned COMEX, for $8.9 billion in cash and stock. The outfit that once traded pork bellies and wheat now lists contracts on interest rates, stock indexes, currencies, energy and metals.

Cboe: the invention of listed options

Cboe has a different origin. It began as the Chicago Board Options Exchange, created by the Board of Trade and opened on April 26, 1973. It was the first exchange to offer standardized, exchange-traded stock options. Before that date, options on stocks were private agreements, hard to price and hard to trade. A standardized contract with a clearinghouse behind it turned the option into something anyone with a broker could use.

On January 19, 1993, the exchange introduced the Cboe Volatility Index, known as the VIX, created by the finance professor Robert E. Whaley to measure the market's expectation of 30-day volatility from S&P 100 option prices. The VIX has since become a common shorthand for market anxiety. The company went public through an initial public offering in June 2010, and in October 2017 it was renamed Cboe Global Markets.

The end of the pits, and a surprise

For more than a century, trading at the exchanges meant shouting. In "open outcry" pits, traders used voices and hand signals to buy and sell, with different gestures for price, quantity and direction. The pits were physical and chaotic, and they were an emblem of Chicago for tourists and filmmakers alike. As electronic platforms took over, the pits shrank. In 2015 CME Group announced that it would close most of its open outcry pits because electronic trading had replaced them.

Then came the twist: some floor trading survived. In June 2022, Cboe's open outcry trading floor opened in the Chicago Board of Trade building, a reminder that the old building is still used for the purpose it was built for, if on a smaller scale.

The banks and the street

An exchange does not work alone. Behind it are the clearing firms that guarantee trades, the brokerages that route customer orders, the banks that lend to them and the trust companies that hold assets. Northern Trust, the Chicago-based bank, is one of the long-established names in this ecosystem. LaSalle Street, which runs from the river south to the Board of Trade Building, has been Chicago's banking street for more than a century, and the towers along it, plus the surrounding blocks of the Loop, hold law firms, accountants and consultants that serve the financial industry. The Loop describes the district as a whole.

That concentration is why the Loop's transit network was built the way it was. The commuter rail terminals, the 'L' loop and the bus routes all deliver workers to the same few blocks. Where Chicagoans work: the city's big employers by sector puts finance beside the city's other major sectors.

What an exchange actually does

A short list, for anyone who has not worked in the business.

  1. It sets the terms. The exchange decides what a contract covers, such as the grade of grain, the size of the lot and the delivery month.
  2. It matches buyers and sellers. Today, mostly by computer; once, in a pit.
  3. It guarantees the trade. A clearinghouse stands between buyer and seller, so neither depends on the other's promise.
  4. It publishes prices. The price of a futures contract is a signal that farmers, manufacturers, airlines and investors watch.
  5. It makes rules and enforces them. Trading conduct, margin requirements and reporting are regulated by the exchange and by federal regulators.

A simple, hypothetical example shows why it matters. Say a cereal maker needs 5,000 bushels of wheat in September and fears prices will rise. It can buy a wheat futures contract now, at today's price for September delivery. If the market price rises, the gain on the contract offsets the higher cost of the wheat. A farmer worried about prices falling can take the opposite side. The exchange's job is to make sure that when September arrives, both sides perform. The numbers are made up for the illustration; the mechanism is the one the Board of Trade's founders were building in 1848.

A timeline of the exchanges

Year Event
1848 The Chicago Board of Trade begins trading in a room above a flour store on South Water Street; the Illinois and Michigan Canal and the first railroad open the same year
1885 The Board of Trade opens a building on the LaSalle Street site, designed by William W. Boyington
1898 The Chicago Mercantile Exchange is founded
1929 The 1885 building is demolished
June 9, 1930 The present Board of Trade Building opens
1973 The Chicago Board Options Exchange opens on April 26
1977 and 1978 The tower becomes a Chicago Landmark and then a National Historic Landmark
1982 The Merc introduces stock index futures
1993 The VIX is introduced on January 19
2000 The Mercantile Exchange demutualizes
2007 CME and the Board of Trade combine as CME Group
2008 CME Group acquires the New York Mercantile Exchange
2010 Cboe's public offering
2015 CME Group announces the closing of most open outcry pits
2017 CBOE Holdings renamed Cboe Global Markets
2022 Cboe's open outcry floor opens in the Board of Trade Building

Read the table top to bottom and you watch an idea move from physical commodities to financial abstractions. Grain and cattle came first, then currencies and stock indexes, then options and volatility, and finally the move from a human crowd to a computer network. At each step, Chicago's exchanges invented or standardized the instrument, then watched others copy it. The city is less a financial capital in the New York sense than a laboratory of risk, where merchants and market designers turned an old idea into new tools.

Why it matters beyond the Loop

The exchanges are not only a Loop story. Prices set in Chicago ripple out to farms across the Midwest, to the hedging done by airlines and manufacturers, and to the retirement accounts of people who have never heard of a futures contract. A decision at the exchanges about contract specifications or margin rules can change how a farmer in Illinois plans a planting season. Inside the city, the exchanges and the firms around them employ thousands of workers in trading, technology, compliance and operations, and a share of the Loop's office space, restaurants and transit ridership depends on them.

Seeing it for yourself

The tower at 141 West Jackson is a working office building, and its lobby is not a museum, but the exterior is visible from the street and from the nearby blocks of LaSalle Street. Chicago's architecture tours often stop at it, and Willis Tower and the Chicago skyline places it within the larger skyline. Anyone interested in the business side will find that the exchanges' own websites describe their contracts and history. Visiting hours, tours and public programs are set by the building's owners and the exchanges and change over time, so check before going.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic