Blog
Haymarket, May 4, 1886
The eight-hour-day rally on Desplaines Street, the bomb, the trial of eight anarchists and the 1893 pardon, with what the record shows and what it leaves open.
A dynamite bomb went off at a labor meeting at Haymarket Square, on Desplaines Street, on the night of May 4, 1886. Within minutes seven police officers and at least four civilians were dead. Eight men went on trial for it. Not one was shown to have thrown the bomb, and only two were even at the square when it exploded. Four were hanged. Six years later a governor pardoned the survivors and wrote that the trial had been unfair. Nearly everything about Haymarket is still argued over, but the outline is not in dispute, and the story reaches around the world. The day most countries celebrate as International Workers' Day, May 1, traces its origin partly to what happened in Chicago that week.
The demand
In the 1880s a long working day was ordinary. The movement for an eight-hour day set a date, May 1, 1886, by which unions across the country hoped to win it, and in the weeks before, the idea ran fast through factories and workshops in cities with big immigrant workforces. Chicago was one of the centers. The city had a large industrial workforce and a strong tradition of labor and radical organizing, including a German-language and an English-language anarchist press. Strikes began on and around May 1 in what is often called the Great Upheaval, and they went on through the days after.
The demand was not only about hours. Workers and organizers argued over pay, over who would control the pace of the work and over whether a shorter day would leave time for study and family. Employers argued that shorter hours would raise costs and cut output. That was the setting for everything that followed.
May 3: the McCormick plant
Monday, May 3. At the McCormick Harvesting Machine Company plant on the Southwest Side, workers had been locked out and replacements were being brought in. Police fired on a crowd of strikers. Two people were killed, though some newspapers reported six. The shooting convinced local anarchists that an answer was needed, and they called a protest meeting for the next evening at Haymarket Square.
May 4: the rally
Haymarket Square was a wide stretch of Randolph Street and Desplaines Street where farmers had once sold hay, and the meeting was set for there. The Tuesday evening rally drew a crowd on a night when the weather turned threatening, and the speakers addressed it from a wagon. It was peaceful, as even those who later called it the work of dangerous agitators generally agreed. As the evening wore on, with rain threatening and the crowd thinning, police moved in to order the meeting to disperse.
Then someone threw a dynamite bomb into the ranks of the police. The blast killed an officer, and the gunfire that followed in the dark and smoke killed more. In all, seven police officers and at least four civilians died, and dozens more were wounded. Historians disagree about who fired first after the explosion, and some of the police casualties were likely caused by friendly fire. Who threw the bomb has never been established.
The trial
In the days after the bombing, police raided meeting halls, newspaper offices and homes, and made mass arrests among anarchists, socialists and immigrant labor activists. Eight anarchists were eventually charged. The charge was conspiracy to commit murder, a theory under which the prosecution did not have to prove any defendant had thrown the bomb, only that they had encouraged violence in speech and writing that someone then acted on. Of the eight, only two had been at the square when the bomb exploded, and none was shown to have thrown it.
All eight were convicted. Seven were sentenced to death and one to 15 years in prison. The trial has been criticized ever since for how the jury was chosen, for the weight given to the defendants' political writings and for the atmosphere of fear in the city. Supporters of the verdict argue that the defendants had called openly for violence and that the jury followed the law as it stood.
Appeals went to the Illinois Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court, and both left the verdict in place. Governor Richard Oglesby commuted two of the death sentences to life in prison. One defendant died in his cell the day before the executions, in an apparent suicide. On November 11, 1887, four men were hanged: August Spies, Albert Parsons, Adolph Fischer and George Engel.
The eight
The men tried were August Spies, Albert Parsons, Samuel Fielden, Michael Schwab, Adolph Fischer, George Engel, Louis Lingg and Oscar Neebe. Several were immigrants, mostly from Germany, and most were active in the anarchist and labor press and in the meetings of the city's workers' groups. Parsons was a native-born American and a printer who had been a prominent speaker for the shorter working day.
Their fates, in order of the sentences:
- Hanged on November 11, 1887: Spies, Parsons, Fischer and Engel.
- Died in his cell the day before: Lingg, in an apparent suicide.
- Sentences commuted to life by the governor: Fielden and Schwab.
- Sentenced to 15 years: Neebe.
- Pardoned in 1893: Fielden, Schwab and Neebe, by Governor Altgeld.
Seven of the eight had been sentenced to death, and one of the seven took his own life before the date.
The pardon
In 1893 Governor John Peter Altgeld pardoned the three men still in prison and let them out. His pardon message did more than forgive. It went after the trial itself, arguing that the jury had been packed and the judge biased. That made Altgeld the target of fierce criticism, and it is often credited with ending his political career. His reasoning and the reaction to it show how the Haymarket case split the city for a generation. To some it proved the state had punished men for their ideas. To others the governor had excused violence.
What changed
For labor, the effect was severe. The bombing set off a harsh anti-union crackdown, and suspicion of immigrant radicals and unions spread through the public. The eight-hour movement of 1886, which had been gaining ground, subsided. Labor organizing carried on and ran through the city's later conflicts. The Pullman strike of 1894 is the next chapter, and the union tradition that grew up in the city is the subject of unions in a union town.
The case also made Haymarket a symbol. It is generally seen as the origin of International Workers' Day on May 1, observed in many countries. In the United States the workers' holiday fell instead on the first Monday of September, Labor Day, which Congress made a federal holiday in 1894.
Where it is remembered
The Haymarket site on Desplaines Street, now in the part of the West Loop covered in West Loop and Fulton Market, was designated a Chicago Landmark in 1992, and a memorial marks the spot where the speakers' wagon stood. The graves of the executed men and of others are at a cemetery in Forest Park, Illinois, where the Haymarket Martyrs' Monument was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1997.
The trial and its appeals belong to the history of the courts that sit in Cook County today, whose current structure is described at Courts and Justice in Chicago, and the police department that answers for public safety is covered in Chicago Police Department. Both are very different institutions from those of 1886.
The case in dates
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| May 1, 1886 | Strikes for the eight-hour day begin across the country, including in Chicago |
| May 3, 1886 | Police fire on strikers at the McCormick plant; two are killed, though some papers reported six |
| May 4, 1886 | Rally at Haymarket Square; a bomb is thrown as police move to disperse the crowd |
| 1886 | Eight men are convicted of conspiracy; seven are sentenced to death and one to 15 years |
| November 11, 1887 | Four men are hanged |
| 1893 | Governor Altgeld pardons the remaining three and criticizes the trial |
| 1992 | The Haymarket site becomes a Chicago Landmark |
| 1997 | The Haymarket Martyrs' Monument in Forest Park becomes a National Historic Landmark |
Questions people ask
Who threw the bomb? It has never been established. The prosecution did not claim to know, which is why the conspiracy theory was used.
Was the rally violent? The rally itself was peaceful. The violence began when police moved in to disperse the crowd near its end and the bomb was thrown.
Were the police killed by the bomb? Some were. The blast and the gunfire afterward killed seven officers, and historians think some of those deaths came from fire by other officers in the confusion.
Why does the world mark May 1? International Workers' Day on May 1 is generally traced to the Haymarket affair and the eight-hour movement of 1886. The American Labor Day, on the first Monday of September, was made a federal holiday in 1894 by a different route, and the two dates are separate traditions.
How to read it fairly
Haymarket is a hard subject because both sides of the old argument still have descendants. A fair reading starts with what the record establishes. There was a peaceful rally. A bomb was thrown, and nobody was ever shown to have thrown it. Police and civilians died. Eight men were convicted on a conspiracy theory. Four were hanged. The governor who pardoned the rest said the trial was unjust. Then it lets readers weigh the rest: who fired first, how much responsibility lay with those who spoke in favor of violence, and what the city's fear in 1886 explains but does not excuse.