Blog

The Pullman strike of 1894

A wage cut in a company town became a national rail boycott, a federal injunction and 12,000 troops in Chicago. What each side argued and what came of it.

The morning of May 11, 1894, about 4,000 workers at the Pullman Palace Car Company put down their tools and walked out of the factory south of the city. Seven weeks on, the strike had grown into a national railroad boycott, and by early July the President of the United States had sent about 12,000 federal troops into Chicago over the objections of the governor of Illinois. When the smoke cleared, roughly 70 people were dead, the union behind the boycott was broken and its leader was in jail. One thing outlasted all of it: Labor Day, made a federal holiday in the middle of the crisis, is the lasting gift to workers that came out of that summer.

A town built by a company

George Pullman made his money building sleeping and parlor cars for the railroads. In the early 1880s he built a town for his workers on the far South Side, near Lake Calumet: brick houses, a church, shops, a library, a theater and a hotel, all laid out as a "model community." Pullman's notion was that a clean, orderly town would produce sober, steady workers, and the company owned every foot of it. Residents paid rent to the company, bought from the company's stores and could not own their homes.

To its admirers the town was an experiment in enlightened management, and visitors came from far off to look. To many of the people who lived there it felt like living inside someone else's rules. The company, as landlord and employer, ran the housing, the services and the paychecks. That arrangement mattered a great deal once the economy turned.

The wage cuts of 1893

The Panic of 1893 dried up orders for railroad cars. Pullman answered by laying off workers and cutting wages by between 20 and 30 percent. He did not cut the rents the company charged in the town, or the prices in its stores.

Run the numbers the way a worker would. Say a man earned $2.00 a day and paid $0.50 of it in rent and company-store purchases that never changed. A 25 percent wage cut leaves $1.50 a day, and with the same $0.50 still going to the company, what remained for everything else falls from $1.50 to $1.00, a one-third drop. The figures are invented for illustration, but the arithmetic is the whole grievance: when pay is cut and costs are not, the cut lands far harder than the percentage suggests.

A committee of workers asked the company to restore wages or lower rents. Pullman's answer was that the company could afford neither, since the contracts it was taking left little margin. The workers pointed out that shareholders had gone right on collecting dividends through the downturn.

May 11: the walkout

On May 11, 1894, about 4,000 workers struck. The Pullman Company would not recognize the American Railway Union, led by Eugene V. Debs, and would not negotiate. The union had signed up a large membership among railroad workers the year before, and many Pullman workers had joined. The union's convention in Chicago in June decided to act.

June 26: the boycott

On June 26 the American Railway Union announced a boycott: its members would refuse to handle any train that carried a Pullman car. It spread down the rail lines with startling speed. At its peak it involved about 250,000 workers in 27 states, and traffic through Chicago, the hub of the national system, was badly snarled.

The railroads fought back through the General Managers' Association, a club of the Chicago-area lines that coordinated their opposition. They fired workers who refused to handle Pullman cars, hired replacements and leaned on the federal government to act. The mail was the legal opening: trains that carried it were federal business, and officials argued that blocking them was a federal crime.

The injunction and the troops

A federal court issued an injunction against the union and its leaders ordering them to stop interfering with the railroads and the mail. Debs and his colleagues did not comply, arguing they had a right to refuse to work.

President Grover Cleveland sent federal troops to Chicago in early July, about 12,000 Army soldiers, over the objections of Illinois Governor John Peter Altgeld, who said the state could keep order itself. The governor's objection was one of principle: the federal government, he argued, had no business sending troops into a state that had not asked for them. Cleveland's reply rested on the need to protect the mail and interstate commerce.

The soldiers did not calm the city. Violence peaked around July 7. Estimates put the deaths at about 70 in all, about 30 in Chicago and roughly 40 elsewhere along the rail lines, and property damage was reported at more than $80 million, much of it in burned rail cars and yards.

Debs in court

Debs was convicted of violating the court order and sentenced to six months in jail. The United States Supreme Court, in a unanimous decision known as In re Debs, upheld the action against him. The decision affirmed the power of federal courts to use injunctions against strikes that interfered with interstate commerce, a tool employers reached for over and over for decades afterward. The American Railway Union dissolved.

A holiday in the middle of it

Congress passed, and President Cleveland signed on June 28, 1894, a law making Labor Day a federal holiday on the first Monday of September. That was five days before he sent the troops. The holiday was signed in the thick of the strike, which is why the two are so often told together.

What became of the town

George Pullman died in 1897. In 1898 the Illinois Supreme Court ruled that the company had to divest itself of ownership of the town, which by then had been annexed to Chicago, finding that a manufacturing company could not hold a town the way Pullman had. The houses were sold to residents and others, and the district became an ordinary neighborhood of the city.

The place has been kept. It is a National Historic Landmark and a Chicago Landmark district, and part of it is managed as Pullman National Historical Park. The brick row houses, the Hotel Florence, the clock tower and the factory buildings are still standing, and the neighborhood is described in Pullman. A wider walk through it is the subject of pullman: a company town inside the city.

The strike in dates

Date Event
1893 The Panic of 1893 cuts orders; Pullman lays off workers and cuts wages 20 to 30 percent while rents stay the same
May 11, 1894 About 4,000 Pullman workers walk out
June 26, 1894 The American Railway Union begins its boycott of trains carrying Pullman cars
June 28, 1894 Labor Day becomes a federal holiday
Early July 1894 About 12,000 federal troops arrive in Chicago; violence peaks around July 7
1894 Debs is convicted of violating the injunction and sentenced to six months; the Supreme Court later upholds the action in In re Debs
1897 George Pullman dies
1898 The Illinois Supreme Court orders the company to give up the town

Questions people ask

Was Pullman the only company involved? No. The Pullman Company made the cars, but the boycott was aimed at the railroads that hauled them, which is why it spread so fast. The railroads' managers organized together through the General Managers' Association.

Did the strikers win? No. The strike ended with the union broken and its leader jailed. The company never met the workers' demands.

Why did the federal government get involved? The mail rode the trains, and the injunction rested on the argument that the boycott interfered with the mail and with interstate commerce.

Why does Labor Day come from this? Congress made it a federal holiday on June 28, 1894, in the middle of the strike. Labor Day on the first Monday of September is a separate tradition from May 1 and the events in Haymarket, May 4, 1886.

Is the town still there? Yes. The brick row houses, the Hotel Florence, the clock tower and the factory buildings have been preserved, and the district is now a neighborhood with a National Park Service site. The National Park Service site is the place to check for current visiting information.

Why it still matters in Chicago

Three things from 1894 are still part of how this city thinks. The first is the idea that a company should not own the place where its workers live; the 1898 ruling that Pullman had to divest the town was an early statement of that principle. The second is wariness about federal troops in city streets, an argument that came back in 1968 (see The 1968 Democratic National Convention in Chicago). The third is the labor tradition itself, with Chicago as a place where unions organize, argue and sometimes lose.

What each side argued

More than a century on, reasonable people still disagree about this one.

  • The strikers and their supporters argued that the company had cut pay while keeping rents and prices high, and that a worker could not live on what was left. They argued that the union had a right to refuse to move Pullman cars.
  • The company and the railroads argued that the downturn left no room to pay more, that the boycott was a sympathy strike against employers that had no dispute with the union and that blocking the mail was unlawful.
  • The federal government argued that its duty was to keep the mail and interstate commerce moving, and used an injunction and troops to do so.
  • Governor Altgeld argued that the state could maintain order itself and that sending in troops without the state's request was an overreach.

The first Chicago labor conflict of the decade is described in Haymarket, May 4, 1886, and the broader tradition of organized labor in the city is in unions in a union town. The courts that ruled on the case are the ancestors of the federal and state systems described in Courts and Justice in Chicago, and the rail lines the strike shut down are part of the story of the region's transit, told in Chicago Transit Authority for the modern system. The rest of Chicago's history in the 1890s, including the fair on the lakefront the year before, is in The World's Columbian Exposition of 1893.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic