Blog
Unions in a union town
From Haymarket in 1886 and the Pullman strike of 1894 to the Memorial Day killings of 1937, the labor history that shaped Chicago's politics and holidays.
The first Monday of September, the country takes a day off. Most people at the cookout do not know that Chicago is part of the reason. On May 1, much of the rest of the world marks International Workers' Day, and that date also runs back to this city. "Union town" is not a slogan here. It is a bill that came due in a series of fights between workers and bosses, some of them among the bloodiest in American labor history, and it has an institution to show for it, the Chicago Federation of Labor, which has sat in city life since the nineteenth century. What follows is the record from the 1880s to the 1930s, and then a look at what is left.
The setting: a city of factories and yards
Start with the economy, because the economy made the fights. By the middle of the nineteenth century Chicago was a crossing of rail and lake, and the businesses that grew up around it were big and tightly held. Cyrus McCormick opened a harvester factory in 1847. The Union Stock Yards opened on December 25, 1865. The Pullman Company built railcars, and a company town to go with them, on the Far South Side. Put thousands of people in a handful of huge workplaces and organizing stops being a theory. One employer's decision about wages could set the weather for an entire neighborhood. rail yards and the freight economy covers the rail network that tied these industries together, and The stockyards and the American meatpacking story covers the yards.
1886: the eight-hour day and Haymarket
In the 1880s a national movement demanded the eight-hour day. Strikes were called for May 1, 1886, and Chicago was the movement's center. On May 3, police fired on strikers at the McCormick Harvesting Machine plant and killed two workers (some accounts say more). The next evening, May 4, a rally was called at Haymarket Square to protest the shootings.
It was a peaceful rally, held under a light rain. As police moved in to break it up, someone threw a homemade dynamite bomb. The blast and the gunfire after it killed seven police officers and at least four civilians and wounded dozens. Nobody ever established who threw it.
What came next has been argued over for well over a century. Eight men, anarchists who had helped organize, were tried for conspiracy. None was shown to have thrown the bomb. All eight were convicted. Seven were sentenced to death and one to fifteen years. Two death sentences were commuted to life, one defendant died by suicide in jail, and four were hanged on November 11, 1887. In 1893 Illinois Governor John Peter Altgeld pardoned the remaining defendants and criticized the trial.
Haymarket is generally treated as the origin of International Workers' Day on May 1. The site was designated a Chicago Landmark in 1992, and a sculpture was dedicated there in 2004. The burial site of the executed men, in Forest Park, Illinois, became a National Historic Landmark in 1997. Haymarket, May 4, 1886 gives the full account.
1889: the settlement house
Not every chapter was a strike. On September 18, 1889, Jane Addams and Ellen Gates Starr opened Hull House on the Near West Side. It was a settlement house: educated reformers living among immigrant working families, running classes and a kindergarten and serving as a base for reform campaigns in a neighborhood of working households. See Hull House and the settlement movement.
1894: Pullman
Pullman showed what one dispute could do to a continental economy. The Pullman Company built sleeping and parlor cars and housed its workers in a model company town, today's Pullman neighborhood. During the Panic of 1893 the company cut wages by 20 to 30 percent and left rents and store prices in the town where they were. On May 11, 1894, about 4,000 Pullman workers walked out.
The American Railway Union, led by Eugene V. Debs, called a boycott of every train that carried a Pullman car. At its peak the boycott reached about 250,000 workers in 27 states and stopped much of the nation's rail traffic. A federal injunction barred the union's leaders from interfering with trains. President Grover Cleveland sent federal troops to Chicago, about 12,000 Army soldiers took part, and Governor Altgeld objected to the deployment. Roughly 30 people were killed in Chicago, and estimates of total deaths run to about 70. The strike collapsed in July. Debs drew six months in prison and the union dissolved.
Five days before the troops arrived, on June 28, 1894, Cleveland had signed the law making Labor Day a federal holiday. A nod to organized labor, in the middle of the same crisis. The full story is in The Pullman strike of 1894.
1896: the Chicago Federation of Labor
On November 9, 1896, the American Federation of Labor chartered the Chicago Federation of Labor, an umbrella for the city's unions. It was meant partly to clean up corruption in the city's labor groups and partly to speak for working people in civic life. The early years were a mess of factional fights and fraud in union elections. In 1906 John Fitzpatrick was elected president and held the office until his death in 1946, forty years that brought a stretch of stability and reform. He oversaw organizing drives in steel and meatpacking in the 1910s and during World War I.
From 1926 to 1979 the federation ran its own radio station, WCFL, the "Voice of Labor." It also affiliated with the Chicago Federation of Teachers and gave the teachers' union movement critical support. By one count in 2011 the federation spoke for about 320 member unions with roughly half a million members in Cook County. As an umbrella body it endorses candidates, lobbies on legislation and sits on civic committees.
1937: Memorial Day
The 1930s brought another wave. The Congress of Industrial Organizations organized by industry rather than craft, and its Steel Workers Organizing Committee won a contract from U.S. Steel. The smaller "Little Steel" companies, Republic Steel among them, refused. On May 30, 1937, Memorial Day, a crowd estimated at between 1,500 and 2,500 people, strikers, families and supporters, set out from the union's headquarters toward the Republic Steel mill on the Southeast Side to picket. About 300 Chicago police blocked the way. Police fired on the crowd as it ran. Ten people were killed, four that day and six later of their injuries. Dozens were wounded, and many were beaten.
A coroner's jury ruled the killings justifiable homicide, and no police officer was prosecuted. A Senate committee held hearings in June and July 1937. Newsreel footage of the event was suppressed, and early newspaper coverage cast the police as acting in self-defense. Memorials to the dead were dedicated in 1967 and 1981, and the sculpture was rededicated in 2008.
How the tradition shaped the city
None of this stayed in the history books.
Holidays and symbols. Labor Day in September and May Day on May 1 are the two holidays the Chicago story helped make. Haymarket is still a place of pilgrimage for labor movements around the world.
Politics. In a city of big workplaces, the labor federations became part of the political machinery. Unions turn up in city elections and in the arguments at City Hall. That history is part of why city jobs, public-sector bargaining and contract negotiations are always a main event, from the school system to the 2027 budget. See The Daley years, 1955 to 1976 for the machine era, when labor and the city administration were closely tangled.
Public employees. Today much of the city's organized labor works in public service: teachers, police and fire personnel, transit workers, city and county employees. Their contracts are tied to public budgets, which is why labor agreements and budgets get fought over together.
Neighborhood memory. Pullman, Back of the Yards and the Southeast Side's steel district carry the story in their buildings and street names. Back of the Yards and Pullman are where the history is easiest to see.
A timeline of labor in the city
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1847 | Cyrus McCormick opens a harvester factory in Chicago |
| December 25, 1865 | The Union Stock Yards open |
| May 3-4, 1886 | Police fire on strikers at the McCormick plant; the Haymarket bombing follows the next evening |
| November 11, 1887 | Four of the convicted Haymarket defendants are hanged |
| September 18, 1889 | Hull House opens on the Near West Side |
| 1893 | Governor Altgeld pardons the remaining Haymarket defendants |
| May 11, 1894 | The Pullman strike begins |
| June 28, 1894 | Labor Day becomes a federal holiday |
| November 9, 1896 | The Chicago Federation of Labor is chartered |
| 1906 | John Fitzpatrick becomes president of the federation |
| May 30, 1937 | Ten people die in the Memorial Day killings at the Republic Steel mill |
Where the history can be seen
You can walk most of it. The Haymarket site, on the near West Side, is a Chicago Landmark with a sculpture dedicated in 2004. The monument at the burial site of the executed defendants is in Forest Park, just west of the city, and is a National Historic Landmark. The Pullman neighborhood on the Far South Side keeps the company town's buildings, and Pullman describes them. The memorial to the men and women killed on Memorial Day 1937 was dedicated in 1967 and again in 1981, and rededicated in 2008. All of these places are public and open to walking. The movement has also left its mark in the names of streets, halls and the buildings where unions still meet.
A word on balance
Labor history is contested, and Chicago's is no exception. The employers and police at Haymarket and Pullman believed they were defending order and property. The workers believed they were defending their livelihoods and their lives. Historians still argue over whether the Haymarket defendants got a fair trial; the 1893 pardon stated the governor's view that they did not. At Pullman, the company argued its wage and rent decisions were business necessities in a depression. The record above is the frame, and the interpretation is the reader's.
Where to go next
The labor story runs through several other pieces. Haymarket, May 4, 1886 and The Pullman strike of 1894 cover the two great nineteenth-century episodes in depth. Where Chicagoans work: the city's big employers by sector places unions among the city's present-day employers. For the current budget and workforce, the city's own pages and the Chicago Federation of Labor's website describe today's organizations.