Blog
Raising the city out of the mud: the 1856 grade decision
How Chicago built its first sewers and raised streets and buildings four to five feet in the 1850s and 1860s, with jackscrews and a hotel that stayed open.
Picture a spring rain in the middle of the nineteenth century. You step off the plank sidewalk and go in to the ankle. Your wagon goes in to the axle. The city sat on land barely higher than Lake Michigan, with water just under the surface and nowhere for it to go. So Chicago did what Chicago does when the ground will not cooperate: it decided to change the ground. Streets went up several feet on fill. The buildings on them went up too, on thousands of screws, and plenty of those buildings stayed open for business while it happened. It was one of the most brazen things any American city ever tried. It also explains why parts of downtown sit where they do, and it shows how this town solves a problem. It builds its way out.
The problem
The ground was low and flat. The lowest point in Chicago today is about 578 feet above sea level at the lake, and the city's mean elevation is about 597. The marshy land by the river had no natural slope toward either the lake or the river, so surface water just stood in the streets. The drinking water came from the lake, near the shore where the waste also drained, and the result was disease. The cholera outbreak of 1854 killed about six percent of the city's population, and that convinced a lot of residents that drainage could not wait any longer.
The numbers show the hurry. A population that went from a few hundred in 1833 to over 4,000 in 1840 and about 90,000 by 1857 (from town to city: 1833 and 1837) was living on ground that had been laid out for a village.
The sewer plan
The answer started with a sewer plan. The engineer Ellis S. Chesbrough drafted a citywide sewerage plan in 1856, and the Common Council adopted it. It was among the first comprehensive systems of its kind in the country. The central idea was a surprising one. The ground was too flat for sewers to drain underground in the usual way, so the city would lay the sewers close to the surface and then build the ground up on top of them. Drains would run to the river, and the river would carry the waste away. Workers laid the pipes and then buried them, and the roads and sidewalks with them, under several feet of soil.
The decision of 1856 is the one usually called the grade decision. The council voted to raise the whole city to a new grade, four to five feet above the old. The work that followed stretched over about a decade and a half. Streets were filled and paved at the new level. That left a problem for everything already standing on them.
Lifting the buildings
A street raised four or five feet left every building on it down in a hole. Doors and ground floors now sat below street level. The owner had two choices: rebuild or lift. Rebuilding was ruinous. Lifting was a new industry.
Most of the buildings went up on jackscrews, big screws set in rows beneath a building's foundation and turned a fraction of a turn at a time by crews of men, so the whole structure rose slowly and evenly. Many old wooden buildings were moved instead: some were demolished, and others were put on rollers and rolled out to the edge of town. Money for the work came from private owners and, in some cases, from public funds. Two contractors, James Brown and James Hollingsworth, became the city's first and busiest building-raising partnership, and others followed.
Some of the jobs are remembered in detail:
| Date | Building | What was done |
|---|---|---|
| January 1858 | A masonry building at Randolph and Dearborn streets | The first masonry building raised; lifted about 6 feet 2 inches on 200 jackscrews, with no reported damage |
| 1860 | Half a city block on Lake Street, between Clark and LaSalle streets | Raised about 4 feet 8 inches by a group of six engineers with 6,000 jackscrews and 600 men |
| 1861 | The Tremont House, a six-story hotel | Raised about 6 feet with 1,000 jackscrews by the firm of Ely, Smith and Pullman, while guests stayed in residence |
| 1865 | The Robbins Building, an iron building | Raised, with its sidewalk, about 27.5 inches with 1,584 jackscrews |
| 1866 | The Briggs House, a brick hotel | Raised, with the hotel in operation |
The Briggs House is the one that gets told and retold. Accounts of the grade decision describe the five-story hotel being lifted while it stayed in operation, with guests coming and going through the work. Imagine checking in to that.
The arithmetic of the jackscrews
The figures in the table invite some comparisons. The first lift, in 1858, used 200 jackscrews to raise a single building 74 inches (6 feet 2 inches). The Lake Street job of 1860 used 6,000 jackscrews, 30 times as many, to lift half a block 56 inches (4 feet 8 inches). The 600 men on that job worked out to 10 screws apiece (6,000 divided by 600). For the Robbins Building, 1,584 jackscrews raised the iron structure 27.5 inches, or about 58 screws per inch of lift. The method depended on many hands acting in unison. To lift a building safely, every screw had to be turned by the same amount at the same time, and a crew chief had to call the signals.
George Pullman
One of the engineers on these projects was a young cabinetmaker from upstate New York named George Pullman. The Tremont House job in 1861, which he took part in, was among the most famous. Pullman went on to build the Pullman Palace Car Company and the company town that carries his name. The neighborhood of Pullman on the Far South Side is described in Pullman, with the strike of 1894 told in The Pullman strike of 1894. There is a certain fitness in a man who made his name raising buildings going on to build a whole town.
A city of mismatched floors
The work did not happen all at once, so for years the city was a patchwork of levels. A raised block stood above a neighbor that had not been raised yet, and a pedestrian might climb or descend steps between a new street and a building still waiting its turn. Some buildings' lowest floors turned into basements. Eventually the work was finished, and the downtown streets lay level with the new grade. The area is described in The Loop.
The water and the river
Raising the streets was only part of the water problem. The sewers emptied into the Chicago River, which flowed into Lake Michigan, so the lake, which was also the source of the city's drinking water, was getting the city's wastewater. The next steps were moving the water intake farther out into the lake, through a tunnel and a crib, and eventually turning the river itself around. The story is in What comes out of the tap: Chicago's water supply and Reversing the river: the Sanitary and Ship Canal. The agencies that run the system now are the Department of Water Management (Chicago Department of Water Management) and the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District (Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago).
How a lift worked, in general
Each job differed in the details, but raising a building on jackscrews followed a general pattern. Crews dug beneath the foundation and set timber cribbing and beams under the walls to carry the load. Screws went in rows along the beams, one worker to each. On a signal from the foreman, every worker gave his screw a small turn, usually a fraction of a full turn, and then waited for the next signal. Repeat that thousands of times and the building rose a little at a time, with masons building up the foundation beneath it as it climbed. The key was uniformity. If one corner moved faster than another, a masonry wall could crack. That is why the reports of the Randolph and Dearborn lift stressed that the building had been raised without damage, and why the owners of the big hotels trusted the work enough to keep their doors open.
A timeline of the lift
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1854 | A cholera outbreak kills about six percent of the population |
| 1856 | Chesbrough's citywide sewer plan is adopted; the council votes to raise the grade |
| January 1858 | The first masonry building is raised, at Randolph and Dearborn |
| 1860 | Half a block on Lake Street is lifted with 6,000 jackscrews |
| 1861 | The Tremont House is raised with guests in residence |
| 1865 | The iron Robbins Building is raised about 27.5 inches |
| 1866 | The Briggs House is raised |
| 1871 | The Great Chicago Fire burns the central city |
| 1900 | The Sanitary and Ship Canal reverses the river |
From the decision of 1856 to the Briggs House lift of 1866 is ten years, a long time for a city to live with torn-up streets and buildings on stilts. It is also a reminder of how fast the place was changing. The population was over 90,000 in 1857, 112,000 in 1860 and 299,000 by 1870, and the builders were raising old structures while new ones went up beside them.
What the whole business teaches
- A city can lift itself. Nineteenth-century Chicagoans accepted enormous costs and risks to solve a public health problem, and they treated a flat, wet site as something to engineer and not a reason to leave.
- Private and public money worked together. Owners paid to lift their buildings, and the city raised the streets.
- The fix made more work. Raising the grade employed hundreds of workers and gave rise to a new trade, and many of the engineers who learned the craft went on to other ventures.
A few years after the work was done, the city burned, and the buildings that had been raised, rebuilt and raised again went up in the fire of 1871 (The Great Chicago Fire of 1871, night by night). The rebuilt city was built at the new grade from the start.