Blog
The Great Chicago Fire of 1871, night by night
How the fire that began behind 137 W. DeKoven Street on October 8, 1871 crossed the river twice, took the water works and burned for two nights.
One inch of rain. That is all Chicago got between July 4 and October 9, 1871, and it explains most of what came after. By the second week of October this was a city built of kindling: more than two-thirds of its buildings were wood from sill to rafter, the roofs were tar or shingle, and plenty of streets and every sidewalk were planked. Fires were routine. The fire department had been fighting them all week, and its crews were played out when the alarm sounded on Sunday, October 8.
Here is the fire in order, from the first call to the last smoldering block, and then what the city did with the wreckage.
Sunday, October 8: the barn on DeKoven Street
It is said to have started around 8:30 in the evening, in or near a small barn behind 137 W. DeKoven Street on the near West Side, on property belonging to the O'Leary family. A shed beside the barn went first. A hard wind out of the southwest shoved the flames northeast, toward the river and the center of town.
The first minutes were squandered. A watchman in the courthouse cupola, the city's lookout, sent crews to the wrong place, and an alarm from a box near the fire never registered at the courthouse. By the time engines reached DeKoven the blaze was moving through the neighborhood's frame cottages and sheds. The department had 185 firefighters and 17 horse-drawn steam pumpers for the whole city. They did what the plan said: set a line south of the river and fight the fire on the West Side, counting on the South Branch of the Chicago River and a patch burned the night before to act as firebreaks.
It did not work, and the reason was what lined the river. Lumber yards, coal yards, warehouses and barges crowded the banks, and the bridges were wooden or carried wooden decks. Burning debris riding the wind did not need a bridge. Around midnight firebrands came down on roofs across the river, including the area of the South Side Gas Works, and the fire was now in the part of the city that held the courthouse, the banks, the hotels and the best commercial blocks.
Monday, October 9, before dawn: the courthouse and the Loop
Mayor Roswell B. Mason sent telegrams to nearby towns asking for engines and men, and help started toward Chicago by rail. When the courthouse caught, he ordered it cleared, and the prisoners in the basement jail were let out. At about 2:30 in the morning the cupola collapsed and the great bell came down with it. Witnesses said the crash carried a mile.
That was the hinge. A big fire became a catastrophe for downtown. The buildings people called fireproof were nothing of the kind, and the business blocks of the Loop proved no safer than the frame houses of the West Side.
Then fire whirls lifted burning matter across the main branch of the river. A burning timber landed on the roof of the water works on the North Side, and once the roof went the pumps stopped. That finished the city's ability to push water through its mains. Firefighters who still had hose and engines found the hydrants dry, and from then on there was nothing left to fight it with. The North Side, where thousands of wooden houses stood shoulder to shoulder on narrow lots, burned through the day.
Thousands of residents ran with what they could carry, ahead of the flames and down streets the fire kept cutting off. The numbers are blunt. The fire burned an area roughly four miles long and three quarters of a mile wide, more than 2,000 acres. It destroyed about 17,500 buildings, more than 73 miles of road, 120 miles of sidewalk and 2,000 lampposts.
Monday night and Tuesday: rain and the last of it
Rain began late Monday, October 9, but by then the fire had eaten the densely built districts and wandered into the thinly built ground at the north end of the city, where there was less to burn. By Tuesday, October 10, it was out. It had lasted from the evening of October 8 to the early hours of October 10.
Nobody ever got an exact count of the dead. About 300 people are estimated to have died, though only about 120 bodies were recovered, and the county coroner said an accurate count was impossible. The homeless number 90,000 in one accounting of the city's roughly 324,000 residents and more than 100,000 in others, a gap that comes from how the displaced were counted. Property losses came to about $222 million, roughly a third of the city's 1871 valuation.
What was left standing
A few buildings were still up. The Chicago Water Tower, a limestone tower on Chicago Avenue finished in 1869, came through; the pumping station beside it lost its roof and was gutted, but its walls were reused. St. Michael's Church in what is now Old Town was gutted, and its brick walls stayed up and were rebuilt into the church that stands there today. Other survivors include the bell tower of St. James Cathedral, which was folded into the rebuilt church, a police constable's cottage at 21 Lincoln Place and two houses on North Cleveland Avenue. The buildings that survived the Great Fire has the longer tour.
Troops, relief and a fixed price on bread
On Wednesday, October 11, Lieutenant General Philip H. Sheridan arrived with troops. The mayor declared martial law and put the city's peace and good order under Sheridan, and regular troops, militia, police and a volunteer regiment patrolled for about two weeks. The troops were relieved on October 24.
Money and goods poured in. New York City sent $450,000 and St. Louis $300,000. Donations came from London and from Greenock, Scotland. Milwaukee sent firefighting equipment. The Chicago Relief and Aid Society handled the money and supplies out of the First Congregational Church. The mayor closed saloons at nine in the evening for a week, and the city fixed the price of a 12-ounce loaf of bread at eight cents. A British gift of more than 8,000 volumes helped found the free public library the City Council approved in April 1872, the start of what is now Chicago Public Library.
Lumber for rebuilding showed up the day the last fire went out. The Palmer House burned 13 days after it opened, and Potter Palmer rebuilt it across the street and called the new hotel the world's first fireproof building.
Rewriting the rules
The rebuilding came with new rules. The council rewrote the city's fire standards, with help from insurance executives and reformers. Frederick Law Olmsted, the landscape architect, was among those who criticized the thin walls and poor construction of the old city, and the rebuilt downtown was far more masonry than wood.
The disaster also set up what came next. The rush to rebuild, with clients willing to pay for fireproof structures, drew architects and engineers from across the country, and it set the stage for the tall steel-frame buildings that arrived a decade later. The Home Insurance Building and the first skyscraper picks up that story.
The cow, the lantern and the 1997 resolution
For generations the story was that Catherine O'Leary's cow kicked over a lantern. The reporter who first printed it, Michael Ahern, retracted it in 1893. Other theories have their advocates: a man named Daniel Sullivan stumbling into the barn with a lantern in search of a drink, or a gambling game in the barn. A meteor theory has been largely set aside by scientists. In 1997 the City Council passed a resolution exonerating the O'Leary family, following research by a local historian. The straight answer is that the fire began in or near that barn and nobody can say what started it.
The same night, by coincidence, the town of Peshtigo in Wisconsin was destroyed by a fire that killed an estimated 1,200 to 2,500 people, the deadliest fire in American history. The telegraph lines went down early, it got little notice, and Chicago's fire became the one remembered.
The fire in numbers
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Rain from July 4 to October 9, 1871 | About 1 inch |
| Firefighters and steam pumpers | 185 firefighters; 17 horse-drawn steam pumpers |
| Start | About 8:30 p.m., Sunday, October 8 |
| Courthouse cupola falls | About 2:30 a.m., Monday, October 9 |
| Deaths | About 300 estimated; about 120 bodies recovered |
| Buildings destroyed | About 17,500 |
| Property loss | About $222 million, a third of the city's valuation |
| Troops relieved | October 24 |
Read the first two lines together and you have the rest: a dry summer and a stretched fire department. The wind and the wooden bridges only made a bad situation worse.
Where to see it today
The site of the O'Leary barn is occupied by the Chicago Fire Academy, the fire department's training facility, which stands on DeKoven Street. The Water Tower is on Michigan Avenue, with the pumping station across the street. The old courthouse, of course, is gone.
For the same event through the eyes of the people who rebuilt, raising the city out of the mud: the 1856 grade decision covers the earlier great engineering change that made the burned city's streets what they were. The department that answers fires today is described at Chicago Fire Department, and current guidance on fire and emergency readiness is in Emergency preparedness in Chicago.