Blog
The Home Insurance Building and the first skyscraper
William Le Baron Jenney's 1884-85 office block at LaSalle and Adams: why it is called the first skyscraper, why historians still argue, and what replaced it.
There is a plaque in a LaSalle Street lobby, put up in 1932, that calls a building nobody can see anymore "the true father of the skyscraper." The building is the Home Insurance Building, and the plaque hangs in the Field Building that replaced it. The original came down in 1931, only 46 years after it was finished, and Chicago has gone back to it ever since only in books, plaques and arguments. The arguments are worth having, though, because they are about how a tall building actually works.
A site at LaSalle and Adams
The Home Insurance Company hired William Le Baron Jenney to design its new headquarters on the northeast corner of LaSalle and Adams streets. Construction began on May 1, 1884, and the building was done in 1885. It went up ten stories to 138 feet, a startling height for an office block in a city where, less than 13 years earlier, nearly everything downtown had burned. Two floors were added in 1891, bringing it to 12 stories and about 180 feet.
The corner explains the building. It sits in the financial heart of the Loop, and in the years after the Great Fire of 1871 the businesses rebuilding downtown wanted two things at once: floor space and protection from fire. The Great Chicago Fire of 1871, night by night tells the fire; what it left behind was a city of burned lots, rising land values and merchants who had learned what an unprotected frame did to their ledgers. A taller, fireproof building let a company squeeze more rentable floor space out of an expensive lot without risking another disaster. Insurers, of all people, had every reason to build one.
What was different about it
A traditional tall masonry building holds itself up with its outer walls. The higher it goes, the thicker the walls have to be at the bottom to carry the weight above, and the less of the ground floor is left for windows and doors. There is a practical limit, and by the early 1880s the tallest masonry buildings in Chicago were pressing against it.
Jenney's building ran on a different logic. It had a fireproof structural frame of metal, iron and steel members carrying the loads of the floors, and the masonry outside was cladding hung on that frame rather than the thing holding the building up. It weighed about a third as much as a comparable masonry building would have, and its outer walls could be thinner and punched with more windows, which in an era before cheap electric light meant brighter offices.
The idea, a skeleton that carries the load and a skin that keeps out the weather, is the basic principle of almost every tall building built since. That is the case for calling it a first.
The city stops the work
Nobody applauded right away. City officials halted construction while they looked into its safety. Frame-carrying construction was new, and the building department had no rulebook for it. The question on the table was whether a building that looked so light could really be as strong as one that looked heavy. Work resumed, and the building was finished.
It is a useful reminder of what a building department is for. The same question comes up with every new method, from the first steel frames to today's mass-timber towers: how does the city decide a new way of building is safe? The modern answer runs through the Department of Buildings, described at Chicago Department of Buildings, and through the permit process that Getting a building permit in Chicago walks through for ordinary projects. In 1884 the system was far simpler, and the city had to work out its answer on the spot.
The claim, and why it is argued
The Home Insurance Building is often called the world's first skyscraper, and by its centennial in 1985 that status was widely accepted. The claim has always been contested, for three reasons.
First, iron-framed buildings existed earlier. An English flax mill, the Ditherington Flax Mill in Shrewsbury, used an iron frame generations before, and the Montauk Building had its own claim. If a skeleton is the test, those buildings got there first. The reply is that they were not tall in the way the word skyscraper implies.
Second, the Chicago press of the time did not hang the name "skyscraper" on the Home Insurance Building. It was applied later, in retrospect, as historians decided which buildings began the story.
Third, the building did not use its metal frame exactly as later buildings would. Historians and engineers have long argued about how much of its weight the frame carried and how much the walls carried. What can be said plainly is that it was an early metal-framed office tower, designed by an architect who understood that a frame could free a building from its walls, and that it was built in Chicago in 1884 and 1885, years before the form spread across the country.
Whether it was the first matters less than that it belongs to a sequence. After it came other tall Chicago buildings of the 1880s and 1890s, among them the Rookery, the Monadnock Building and the Reliance Building, each pushing on a different part of the same problem. Together they are what people mean by the Chicago School of architecture.
A skeleton in three steps
Picture a ten-story building and ask what holds up the top floor.
- In a masonry building, the top floor rests on the walls below it, and those walls rest on the walls below them. The bottom wall carries everything above it, so it has to be the thickest, and the windows at street level have to be small.
- In a skeleton-frame building, the floors hang on a grid of vertical columns and horizontal beams. Each floor passes its weight into the grid, and the grid passes it down to the foundation. The outer wall is hung from the frame, floor by floor, and carries only its own weight.
- The result is a building that can be tall without a heavy base, with a lighter and more fireproof structure and more window area on every floor.
That is the leap the building is credited with. Add the passenger elevator, which made upper floors as rentable as lower ones, and you have the conditions that made the skyscraper a commercial form rather than a stunt.
The building in dates
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1871 | The Great Chicago Fire burns the central business district |
| May 1, 1884 | Construction begins at LaSalle and Adams |
| 1885 | The ten-story building is completed |
| 1891 | Two floors are added, bringing it to 12 stories |
| April 1929 | The building is 90 percent occupied |
| 1931 | It is demolished to make way for the Field Building |
| 1932 | A plaque in the Field Building lobby honors it |
| 1985 | Its centennial, when its status as the first skyscraper is widely accepted |
Questions people ask
Was it the tallest building in the world? No. It was tall for its time and its type, ten stories and 138 feet at first, but its claim rests on how it was built, not on its height. The height record passed to other buildings quickly. Chicago's later claim, the Sears Tower of 1974, stood at 1,451 feet and was then the tallest building in the world; it is now the Willis Tower.
Did the city really stop the construction? Yes. City officials halted work while they examined its safety, and work resumed afterward.
Can I see anything of it? The building is gone, and the plaque is in the lobby of the building that replaced it. The best view of the same streetscape is from the sidewalk at LaSalle and Adams, looking up at the stone-clad towers that followed it.
Decline and demolition
By the late 1920s the building had lost its edge. It was 90 percent occupied in April 1929, against 96 percent or more for the surrounding financial district, a gap that suggests tenants were choosing newer space. The market was building much taller. The Board of Trade Building opened in 1930, and the skyline was being rewritten in the Art Deco style that dominated the next decade.
In 1931 the Home Insurance Building was demolished to make way for Marshall Field's Field Building, the tower that still stands at the corner. The 1932 plaque in the new lobby is a gesture of respect from the people who had just torn the old one down.
What to look for in the Loop
You cannot visit the Home Insurance Building, but you can visit the neighborhood it grew up in, and the Loop is a compact place to read the history of tall buildings in order. Some things to look for as you walk:
- The corner of LaSalle and Adams. The Field Building is there now. The 1932 plaque is in the lobby.
- The financial district around LaSalle Street. It is where the new fireproof buildings of the 1880s and 1890s clustered, and the street still has a canyon feel.
- Masonry versus frame. Compare a heavy stone-faced building with one whose facade is mostly glass and metal. The difference you see is the difference Jenney's building began.
A longer walk is described in A walk under the Loop elevated, block by block, and The architecture tour: from the Home Insurance Building to Willis Tower looks at the same buildings from the water. The skyline's later chapter, the tallest building in the world for a quarter century, is the subject of Willis Tower and the Chicago skyline. For the district as a whole, see The Loop.
Why it still matters
Every tall building built since owes something to the idea tested at LaSalle and Adams, and the city that tried it first still argues the question of how to build high as a living civic one: how tall, where, under what rules. The Home Insurance Building is gone. It left a standard behind, a way of describing what the Loop's architects were doing in the 1880s, and a reminder that a skyscraper is a technology and not just a shape.