Blog
The buildings that survived the Great Fire
A short tour of the Water Tower, St. Michael's, Old St. Patrick's and the other structures that stood through the October 1871 fire, and why the count varies.
Ask how many buildings survived the Great Chicago Fire and nobody agrees. Some lists say six, some say seven, and the number turns on what you are willing to count: a church that burned out but kept its walls, a cottage in the path of the fire that somehow came through, a building that stood just outside the burned district and never met the flames. The fire of October 8 to 10, 1871 destroyed about 17,500 structures across more than 2,000 acres, so anything left standing in that zone is a survivor by any definition. The handful that remain are among the most carefully looked-after buildings in town. The night-by-night account of the fire itself is in The Great Chicago Fire of 1871, night by night; this is a walk through what is left.
The Water Tower
The famous one is the Chicago Water Tower, at 806 North Michigan Avenue. William W. Boyington designed it, and it was finished in 1869, two years before the fire. It is built of limestone from Lemont, Illinois, in a castellated Gothic style, and it enclosed a standpipe, a tall vertical pipe that evened out the pressure of the water pumped through the city's mains. It is the second-oldest water tower in the United States, after the one in Louisville, Kentucky.
The tower stood in the fire's path on the North Side and was still there when the fire had passed. The buildings around it burned; the tower did not. It is solid limestone, which gave the flames little to work with. The pumping station beside it, the building that actually moved the water, lost its roof, and that cut off the water to the city's mains in the middle of the fire. The tower came through. The water system it belonged to did not.
The tower became a symbol of the city's recovery. Oscar Wilde, who saw it, thought the building ridiculous, a castle with pepper pots stuck all over it by his account, though he admired the machinery inside. Major repair work followed in 1913 to 1916, when many limestone blocks were replaced, and again in 1978, mostly inside. The tower was named an American Water Landmark in 1969 and is a contributing property in the Old Chicago Water Tower District on the National Register of Historic Places.
Today it stands at the center of Jane M. Byrne Plaza, named in 2014 for the city's first woman mayor, and it houses the City Gallery, run by the city's cultural department, Chicago Department of Cultural Affairs and Special Events. The shopping tower called Water Tower Place across the street took its name from it. You can look at the tower from the sidewalk for nothing, which makes it one of the easiest stops on Free things to do in Chicago.
The Chicago Avenue Pumping Station
Across Chicago Avenue sits the pumping station, a companion building in the same stone. It drew water from Lake Michigan and pushed it into the mains, and the fire got to it because its roof was not limestone. When the roof burned the pumps stopped, and the hydrants of the city ran dry. The interior was gutted, but the walls stood and were reused. It is one of the only public buildings in the burned district that came through, and it still stands beside the tower. The wider story of how the city has supplied water since, from the intake cribs to the filtration plants, is told through Chicago Department of Water Management.
St. Michael's in Old Town
The parish of St. Michael was founded in 1852 for German and Luxembourgish Catholic immigrants, and its first wooden church cost $750, bell included. A large brick church was finished in 1869, and its tower made it the tallest building in Chicago, and in the United States, until the Board of Trade Building went up in 1885. The Redemptorist order of priests, invited to run the parish in 1860, still staffs it.
The fire gutted the church, and its brick walls stood. It was among the first churches in the city to be rebuilt, and the church standing today at Eugenie Street and Cleveland Avenue incorporates those walls. Shortly after the fire, parish members formed a mutual aid society, the Luxemburger Unterstuetzungs Verein, described as the first Luxembourgish-American organization in the United States. A local saying holds that if you can hear the church's bells, you are in Old Town. The neighborhood around it is covered in Old Town and Old Town: Victorian Chicago that survived the fire, and the rows of frame and brick houses on its side streets are among the best places to see what the city looked like just after the rebuilding.
Old St. Patrick's, just outside the line
Old St. Patrick's Church at 700 West Adams Street went up in the 1850s and is the city's oldest standing church building. It was not in the fire's path; the fire stopped short of it, helped by the direction of the wind. It is one of a handful of structures in the city that predate 1871. By the 1880s most of its parish was Irish American. From 1912 through 1922 its interior was redecorated by Thomas A. O'Shaughnessy and others in the Celtic Revival style, with some ornament modeled on the illuminated pages of the Book of Kells. The building was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1977, and the parish holds an annual summer block party that it bills as the world's largest.
The cottage and the Cleveland Avenue houses
The smaller survivors are houses. A cottage at 21 Lincoln Place, built for a police constable named Bellinger, is among the buildings listed as having made it through the fire, and so are the houses at 2339 and 2343 North Cleveland Avenue. They are a reminder that the Chicago of 1871 was mostly small frame houses, and that the story we tell of grand stone buildings falling to the flames leaves out the workers' cottages that made up most of the city.
The bell tower of St. James Cathedral was also left standing and was worked into the rebuilt church.
What the survivors say about the fire's path
Put the survivors on a map and they sketch the fire's route. The fire began on the West Side at DeKoven Street, jumped the South Branch of the Chicago River around midnight on October 8 and burned through what is now the Loop. After the courthouse cupola fell at about 2:30 in the morning on October 9, burning debris crossed the main branch of the river and set the North Side alight, and a burning timber landed on the roof of the water works on Chicago Avenue. The Water Tower, the pumping station and St. Michael's all sit on that northern leg of the fire, in the part of the city where tightly packed frame houses burned through Monday. Old St. Patrick's lies west of the river, on the far side of the line from the burned zone, which is why it counts as a pre-fire survivor without ever having been tested by flames.
The fire finally burned itself out because it ran into ground with less to burn at the north end of the city, and because rain began to fall late on Monday. By then the burned district was about four miles long and three quarters of a mile wide. Everything inside it was a bet against the wind, and the survivors are the places where the bet came out right.
After the fire
Rebuilding started almost at once. Lumber for new buildings arrived the same day the last fire went out, and St. Michael's parish was putting up temporary wooden structures within a week. Relief money came from New York ($450,000), St. Louis ($300,000), London and Greenock, Scotland, and the Chicago Relief and Aid Society handled distribution from the First Congregational Church. A gift of more than 8,000 volumes from Britain helped start the free public library that the City Council approved in April 1872.
The city also rewrote its fire standards. Hotelier Potter Palmer, whose Palmer House burned 13 days after it opened, rebuilt across the street and advertised the new hotel as the first fireproof building in the world. Frederick Law Olmsted criticized the thin walls and poor construction of the old city.
Why the list stays uncertain
There are good reasons the count varies. A building might be "standing" but gutted, like St. Michael's and the pumping station. A building might have been rebuilt on its old walls. A house might have been altered over the next century and a half. The safest way to describe the group is as a handful of buildings with a solid claim: the Water Tower, the pumping station, St. Michael's, the bell tower of St. James, the constable's cottage and the two Cleveland Avenue houses, with Old St. Patrick's as the best-known pre-fire building that sat outside the burned district.
What most of the survivors share is material. Limestone and brick did better than wood, and walls did better than roofs: the pumping station and St. Michael's both kept their walls and lost nearly everything else. The rebuilt city carried that lesson into its fire standards.
A walking route
The survivors make a tidy route if you start on Michigan Avenue and finish on the other side of the Near North Side. The Water Tower and the pumping station face each other across the street. From there it is a bus ride or a long walk north and west to Old Town, where St. Michael's stands at Eugenie and Cleveland, with the Cleveland Avenue houses a few blocks off. Old St. Patrick's is a separate trip, in the West Loop. The neighborhoods near the Water Tower are the subject of The Gold Coast Historic District on foot; the Chicago History Museum, on the edge of Lincoln Park, keeps the city's collections on the fire.